Regular TV Access Tied to Preference for Thinner Women
When people have access to daily television, they tend to prefer thinner women, according to a new body image study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
For the study, U.K. researchers from Durham University observed 299 men and women from seven villages in the Pearl Lagoon Basin, a remote area of Nicaragua. The participants either had regular TV access or hardly any at all. The participants completed a questionnaire about their ethnicity, education, income, hunger, language and TV exposure. They were then asked to rate the attractiveness of pictures of female bodies with varying body shapes and sizes.
The findings show that Nicaraguans with very limited access to TV preferred female figures with a higher body mass index (BMI) whereas those who often watched TV preferred thinner bodies.
The villages in Nicaragua were selected because people were very similar in terms of their ecological constraints, such as nutrition, income and education, but had differing access to TV. This meant researchers were able to isolate the effect of TV exposure from the other factors.
The researchers said this is the best evidence to date that TV is having a causal effect on people’s perceptions of body ideals. The representation of this “thin ideal” in the media can lead to body dissatisfaction and can play a part in the development of eating disorders and depression.
“TV and advertising bosses have a moral responsibility to use actors, presenters and models of all shapes and sizes and avoid stigmatizing larger bodies,” said lead author Professor Lynda Boothroyd from Durham University’s psychology department.
“There needs to be a shift towards a ‘health at every size’ attitude and the media has an important role to play in that.”
People in the villages in this part of Nicaragua generally did not have access to magazines or the Internet, and none of the participants in the study owned a smartphone. Only those people with electricity supplies to their homes as well as the money to pay for a TV and subscription were able to watch TV on a regular basis.
Those people with access to TV watched a mixture of Latin soap operas, Hollywood action movies, music videos, police “car chase” reality shows and the news.
“This study, utilizing a range of quantitative and qualitative research methods with non-Western participants, provides yet more empirical evidence that the mass media impact female body size ideals,” said co-author, Dr. Jean-Luc Jucker from Durham University and University of the Autonomous Regions of the Nicaraguan Caribbean Coast.
In addition to this study, the team also carried out another study among those villagers who had little or no TV access.
“We showed the villagers a series of pictures, either showing larger women or thinner women. We found that after viewing these images, the villagers’ body ideals adjusted in the same direction,” said Dr. Tracey Thornborrow from the University of Lincoln, co-author and field researcher on the project.
“Our findings clearly demonstrate that perceptions of attractiveness are highly changeable, and are affected by what we are visually exposed to.”
Boothroyd previously found the same results in women in Western societies, but this effect had never been tested outside industrialized societies before.
Being able to show that perceptions of attractiveness are this changeable in even “media-naïve” participants is a major step forward in our understanding of cultural variation, according to the researchers. “If there’s something that’s universal about attraction, it is how flexible it is,” Boothroyd said.
Source: Durham University
Pedersen, T. (2019). Regular TV Access Tied to Preference for Thinner Women. Psych Central. Retrieved on July 12, 2020, from https://psychcentral.com/news/2019/12/26/regular-tv-access-tied-to-preference-for-thinner-women/152828.html