How quickly a person spends his retirement savings may have as much or more to do with his personality than whether he has a lot of debt or wants to leave an inheritance, according to a new study published in the journal Psychology and Aging.
The findings show that people who are more agreeable or more open to new experiences — or those who are more neurotic or negative — might spend their retirement savings at a faster rate than those who are more extroverted or have a positive attitude.
“Little is known about what personally motivates retirees to withdraw money from their investment portfolios as most studies on portfolio withdrawal rates address technical issues, such as minimizing risk of financial shortfall or making spending adjustments based on perceived life expectancy,” said lead author Sarah Asebedo, Ph.D., of Texas Tech University in Lubbock, Texas.
“The purpose of this study was to investigate how personality traits are related to portfolio withdrawal decisions of retirees.”
For the study, Asebedo and coauthor Christopher Browning, Ph.D., also of Texas Tech, analyzed the personality and psychological data of more than 3,600 people in the United States, age 50 or older (the average age was 70), in the 2012 and 2014 waves of the Health and Retirement Study.
The data were paired with tax data from the same participants to account for withdrawals from individual retirement accounts. The researchers only used participants who made withdrawals from their retirement accounts and other saving accounts.
Participants were scored on what many psychologists call the “Big Five” personality traits: Openness to experience (i.e., they are creative, imaginative, adventurous and curious), conscientiousness (i.e., they are organized, thorough, hardworking and cautious), extroversion, agreeableness (i.e., they are sympathetic, caring, warm and helpful) and neuroticism (i.e., they are nervous, worrying, moody and not calm).
The researchers also looked at data about the amount of control participants perceived they had over their financial situation and to what extent they felt a variety of positive and negative emotions over the previous 30 days.
“We found that those with greater conscientiousness, extroversion, positive emotions and feelings of control over their finances withdrew from their retirement portfolios at a lower rate than those with greater openness, agreeableness, neuroticism and negative emotions,” Asebedo said.
The results remained even after the researchers factored in portfolio withdrawal decisions, such as the expectation of leaving an inheritance, age, marital status and mortgage debt.
Asebedo believes this may be the first study to look at the role personality traits play in how quickly individuals spend their retirement portfolio and is an important contribution to a field of study that has historically focused on technical rather than human factors.
The findings suggest that financial professionals should take the personality traits of their clients into account when developing retirement strategies instead of focusing entirely on their clients’ financial situations, said Asebedo.
A higher withdrawal rate is not necessarily a bad thing nor is a lower withdrawal rate always good, she warned.
“A higher portfolio withdrawal rate is concerning if it places the individual on a path to run out of money too early. However, if the higher portfolio withdrawal rate does not run the risk of running out of money, then it may very well be facilitating a life well-lived,” Asebedo said.
“Similarly, a lower withdrawal rate is a good thing if it facilitates controlled spending from the portfolio at a level that protects it from early depletion. If the individual is under-spending and forgoing experiences that they would enjoy because of a saving habit they are unable to break, then the low withdrawal rate is a missed opportunity to maximize the life that they have saved for.”