How Girls & Boys with Autism Tell Stories May Be Key to Missed Diagnoses in Girls
Boys are four times more likely than girls to be diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder (ASD), yet a growing body of research shows that the condition is more common in girls than previously thought, suggesting that new methods are required to diagnose the disorder at younger ages.
Previous research suggests that how a child tells a story can predict certain social deficits tied to ASD. For example, it was believed that kids with autism use far fewer “cognitive process” words such as “think” and “know” during storytelling. And while past studies used primarily male participants, the results were assumed to generalize to girls.
Now a new study shows that girls with autism use significantly more cognitive process words than autistic boys, despite comparable autism symptom severity.
The findings are published in the journal Molecular Autism.
“In order to place these findings in context, it’s important to understand that because girls tend to exhibit different traits than autistic boys do, they are often incorrectly diagnosed or missed entirely by standard diagnostic tools. That discrepancy also skews the research literature,” explained lead author Julia Parish-Morris, Ph.D., a scientist in the Center for Autism Research and faculty member in the Departments of Child Psychiatry and Biomedical & Health Informatics at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP).
“Autism studies have historically included three to six times as many males as females. This means that we don’t yet know enough about gender differences in autism, and so we miss girls whose traits differ from those of boys.”
Missed diagnoses means many girls do not receive early interventions and that standard interventions may not be appropriate for meeting girls’ unique needs. In fact, many females with autism are not diagnosed until they are adults and report significant social challenges and a profound sense of being different from their typically developing peers.
“Autism is a social condition diagnosed using observable behavior, so we wanted to study an observable skill that relates to social ability,” Parish-Morris said. “We chose storytelling because it involves much more than grammar and vocabulary; it relies on a sense of social appropriateness and sheds light on what speakers decide is important to convey.”
For the new study, the researchers focused on how participants used nouns (object words) compared with cognitive process words. They evaluated 102 verbally fluent school-aged children who either had a diagnosis of ASD (21 girls and 41 boys) or were typically developing (19 girls and 21 boys), and were matched on age, IQ and maternal education. The children viewed a sequence of pictures showing a fisherman, a cat and a bird, and told a story based on what they saw.
The findings reveal that autistic girls used significantly more cognitive process words than autistic boys did, even when they had similar levels of autism severity. In fact, girls with ASD and typical girls used comparable numbers of cognitive process words.
Interestingly, autistic boys and girls both used more nouns than typically developing children, demonstrating object-focused storytelling. Thus, autistic girls showed a unique narrative profile that overlapped with typical girls and boys as well as with autistic boys.
“Through storytelling, we were able to identify key similarities and differences in the language patterns of autistic girls and boys,” Parish-Morris said.
“These findings suggest that sex-informed screening and diagnostic methods may help us identify autism in verbal girls at an earlier age, which should spur efforts to develop appropriate, personalized early interventions resulting in improved support for girls and women with ASD.”
Pedersen, T. (2019). How Girls & Boys with Autism Tell Stories May Be Key to Missed Diagnoses in Girls. Psych Central. Retrieved on July 16, 2020, from https://psychcentral.com/news/2019/05/06/how-girls-boys-with-autism-tell-stories-may-be-key-to-missed-diagnoses-in-girls/144923.html