Depression in Black Teens May Require Different Treatment Approach

Emerging research suggests black adolescents show different depressive symptoms than people from other age and racial groups.

This knowledge has lead Rutgers University-Camden researchers to recommend that clinicians adjust their treatment plans to ensure appropriate interventions.

“Adolescent depression is a dire public concern in the United States, and even greater concern among Black adolescents, where, if left untreated, can disproportionately lead to an escalation of various mental disorders, academic failure, and related issues,” said Dr. Wenhua Lu, an assistant professor of childhood studies.

Lu and fellow researchers Dr. Michael Lindsey of New York University, Sireen Irsheild, M.S.W., of University of Chicago, and Dr. Von Eugene Nebbitt of Washington University explored the way black adolescents conceptualize and present symptoms of depression.

The study appears in the Journal of the Society for Social Work and Research.

Researchers discovered Black adolescents experiencing depressive symptoms tend to express their depressed feelings by complaining about conflicts with others and physical pains.

“When assessing and treating black adolescents’ depression, clinicians need to pay particular attention to their complaints about interpersonal struggles and physical discomfort,”  said Lu.

“Treatments such as interpersonal psychotherapy may work better for this population.”

The researchers note the great significance of determining these depressive symptoms among Black adolescents.

Previous studies, they explain, have shown that black adolescents who live in disadvantaged community environments — for example, urban public housing — are more likely to experience elevated levels of substance abuse, violence, and poverty.

“Black adolescents who are exposed to such environmental and social risk factors without sufficient social-support networks are at a higher risk of depression,” said Lu.

Significantly, youth who have been diagnosed with depression are six times more likely to commit suicide than their peers, and black youth have a much higher suicide rate than their White peers.

“It is imperative, therefore, to identify the unique ways Black adolescents express depressive symptoms, and calibrate existing assessment tools to improve their psychometric property for this population,” the researchers write in the study.

A total of 792 black adolescents, ages 11 to 21, who lived in nine public housing developments in four major U.S. cities (including two in North Philadelphia), participated in the study.

Adolescents completed a survey that contained a mixture of 20 negatively and positively worded items — such as such as “I felt sad,” “I enjoyed life,” “My appetite was poor,” and “People are unfriendly to me” — in the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D).

Lu explains that the CES-D is a commonly used self-report tool to assess depressive symptoms in community-based populations, and the 20 items are usually grouped into four major domains: depression affect, somatic symptoms, interpersonal relations and positive affect.

“However, this scale was developed primarily to assess clinical depression among white adults,” says Lu. “It has not been fully validated as a screening tool in black adolescents.”

Source: Rutgers University