Stress Triggers Depression in Women, Alcohol Cravings in Men
An interesting new study finds that women and men tend to have different types of stress-related psychological disorders.
In the study of emotional and alcohol-craving responses to stress, scientists discovered that when men become upset, they are more likely than women to want alcohol.
“We know that women and men respond to stress differently,” said Tara M. Chaplin, associate research scientist at Yale University School of Medicine and first author of the study.
“For example, following a stressful experience, women are more likely than men to say that they feel sad or anxious, which may lead to risk for depression and anxiety disorders. Some studies have found that men are more likely to drink alcohol following stress than women. If this becomes a pattern, it could lead to alcohol-use disorders.”
As part of a larger study, the researchers exposed 54 healthy adult social drinkers (27 women, 27 men) to three types of imagery scripts — stressful, alcohol-related, and neutral/relaxing – in separate sessions, on separate days and in random order. Chaplin and her colleagues then assessed participants’ subjective emotions, behavioral/bodily responses, cardiovascular arousal as indicated by heart rate and blood pressure, and self-reported alcohol craving.
“After listening to the stressful story, women reported more sadness and anxiety than men,” said Chaplin, “as well as greater behavioral arousal. But, for the men … emotional arousal was linked to increases in alcohol craving. In other words, when men are upset, they are more likely to want alcohol.”
These findings — in addition to the fact that the men drank more than the women on average — meant that the men had more experience with alcohol, perhaps leading them to turn to alcohol as a way of coping with distress, added Chaplin.
“Men’s tendency to crave alcohol when upset may be a learned behavior or may be related to known gender differences in reward pathways in the brain,” she said. “And this tendency may contribute to risk for alcohol-use disorders.”
There is a greater societal acceptance of “emotionality,” particularly sadness and anxiety, in women than in men, noted Chaplin.
“Women are more likely than men to focus on negative emotional aspects of stressful circumstances, for example, they tend to ‘ruminate’ or think over and over again about their negative emotional state,” she said.
“Men, in contrast, are more likely to distract themselves from negative emotions, to try not to think about these emotions. Our finding that men had greater blood pressure response to stress, but did not report greater sadness and anxiety, may reflect that they are more likely to try to distract themselves from their physiological arousal, possibly through the use of alcohol.”
Due to the very small sample size used in the present study, the results should be taken with caution. They would need to be replicated by other researchers before they could be generalizeable to a broader population. It is not clear what psychological or personality factors may also be attributable to the findings, since the researchers did not control for these variables.
Results were published in the July 2008 issue of Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research .
Source: Yale University
This article has been updated from the original version, which was originally published here on May 12, 2008.
Nauert PhD, R. (2019). Stress Triggers Depression in Women, Alcohol Cravings in Men. Psych Central. Retrieved on July 2, 2020, from https://psychcentral.com/news/2017/05/12/stress-triggers-depression-in-women-alcohol-craving-in-men/2266.html