New research explores the role that ethnic identity might play in obesity and physical activity, especially as it relates to hairstyle choices.
Researchers led by childhood obesity expert Susan Woolford, M.D., M.P.H., acknowledged that some girls and women in the black community feel as if they have to choose between their health and their hair.
Gym class, school sports, and other exercise routines bring important health benefits. But sweating also means potentially bad hair days and ruining time-consuming and costly hairstyles.
This issue led Woolford, a pediatrician at the University of Michigan’s C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital, to study this cultural phenomenon along with her sister Carole Woolford-Hunt, Ph.D., of Andrews University in Michigan, and David Williams, Ph.D., of Harvard University, to study this cultural phenomenon.
The researchers asked: Are lower levels of physical activity among African-American teens related to hair care?
The small study, which was recently published in BMC Obesity, included 36 African-American girls ages 14 to 17 in three states.
The authors found a consistent theme among participants: Adolescent girls preferred straightened hair, which was viewed as the most “attractive” style, and said they avoided getting wet or sweating during exercise because they worried it would ruin their hairstyle.
Woolford, who is herself black, said the findings are meaningful.
She said African-American children and women have a disproportionately high risk of obesity compared with their Caucasian peers. Interestingly, this difference becomes more apparent as girls get older. At ages six to 11, the obesity rates are more similar. But by adolescence there is a marked difference (about 14 percent versus 29 percent).
“It’s really important that we examine all possible factors that could contribute to this disparity. One of them is that African-American girls may not be as physically active during adolescence, and we need to ask why,” Woolford said.
“My sister and co-investigator, Dr. Woolford-Hunt, is a counseling psychologist and an expert in issues related to race and culture. We have often discussed the role that ethnic identity might play in obesity and physical activity, especially as it relates to hairstyle choices. Some people may be surprised that hairstyle concerns could potentially affect physical activity.”
But, we got the opposite reaction from those who are familiar with this issue, such as my hairdresser who said, “Well, everyone knows that’s true. Why would you need to do a study to show that?”
Current fashion styles are not helpful. Woolford explains that because of cultural pressure, many black women in the U.S. go to great lengths to relax and straighten their natural hair.
Many popular hairstyles require hair weaving or some form of straightening process, which can be expensive, time consuming, and reversed by exposure to moisture. Frizzy sections of hair are undesirable, and it is often socially unacceptable to let natural hair emerge.
There is also a perception among some that to be accepted in mainstream America — particularly in corporate America — straighter hair is more appropriate than braided, locked, or natural hair. There is also the possibility that in order to advance in some careers or to be socially accepted, having a look that mirrors the majority culture is helpful because the less “different” you are, the more comfortable others are around you. There’s sometimes a negative connotation placed on a very “ethnic” look.
Other studies have suggested that as many as 40 percent of adult black women have at one time avoided exercise because of concerns that it would ruin their hair.
In the current research, investigators were we were struck by how consistent the message was from state to state. There were some nuances (adolescents in Georgia were more accepting of natural styles than those in Michigan and California, for example). But long, straight hair was consistently seen as most desirable.
Four main themes emerged:
- when concerns about hairstyles began between ages eight and 15, participants changed from “juvenile” (natural) styles to “adult” (straightened) styles;
- participants avoided getting wet or sweating during exercise because their straightened hair became “nappy;”
- braids with extensions and natural styles were viewed as better for exercise, but not viewed as attractive;
- participants almost universally selected long, straight hairstyles as most attractive. Some thought short, natural hair was OK but that it “only looks good on some people.”
“It’s important to note that while we found common themes through all focus groups, not every African-American adolescent feels this way. However, this issue does seem to be on the minds of many African-American teenage girls and warrants further exploration,” said Woolford.
She goes on to explain that if ethnic identity or hairstyle preferences do indeed impact physical activity, maybe interventions to address excess weight and unhealthy lifestyle preferences could be tailored around these issues.
“Much of my research explores the use of text messaging tools to help adolescents achieve a healthy weight, and our findings reinforce my interest in studying how we might incorporate texts tailored to this issue. For example, we could include photos of people with natural or braided hair exercising to encourage or inspire teens to do the same.”
Another issue is that of ethnic identity.
Woolford adds, “Ethnic identity has been shown to be related to lifestyle and hairstyle choices, so we measured it in this study. Something we hadn’t seen in the literature before was whether someone’s ethnic identity impacts physical activity, coupled with the idea that a stronger association with an ethnic group may make someone more comfortable with natural hair and therefore more willing to exercise.
“Even in such a small sample, it was interesting to see an association between higher levels of ethnic identity and higher levels of reported physical activity. We also found an association between hairstyle choice and level of physical activity (measured by self-reported minutes of activity that increased heart rate, such as sports participation).”
All researchers believe additional studies are needed to replicate the current study and to explore how ethnic identity is influenced by our society and how this impacts health.
Source: University of Michigan