Home » News » Should You Trust Your Gut or Carefully Analyze the Situation?
Should Trust Your Gut or Carefully Analyze the Situation?

Should You Trust Your Gut or Carefully Analyze the Situation?

Is empathy the result of gut intuition or careful reasoning?

A new study suggests that, contrary to popular belief, trusting your gut is not always the best approach.

“Cultivating successful personal and professional relationships requires the ability to accurately infer the feelings of others — that is, to be empathically accurate. Some are better at this than others, a difference that may be explained in part by mode of thought,” said Jennifer Lerner, Ph.D., of Harvard University, a co-author of the study.

“Until now, however, little was known about which mode of thought, intuitive versus systematic, offers better accuracy in perceiving another’s feelings.”

People process information and make decisions in different ways, according to Lerner. Some choose to follow their instincts and go with what feels right to them — intuitive — while others plan carefully and analyze the information available to them before deciding — systematic.

Lerner and her co-author, Christine Ma-Kellams, Ph.D., of the University of La Verne, conducted four studies, involving more than 900 participants, to examine the relationship between the two modes of thought and empathetic accuracy.

The first study determined that most people believe that intuition is a better guide than systematic thinking to accurately infer another’s thoughts and feelings. The other three studies found that the opposite is true, according to the researchers.

“Importantly, three out of the four studies presented here relied on actual professionals and managers. This sample represents a highly relevant group for which to test empathic accuracy, given the importance of empathic accuracy for a host of workplace outcomes, including negotiations, worker satisfaction, and workplace performance,” said Ma-Kellams.

These findings show that commonly held assumptions about what makes someone a good emotional mind reader may be wrong, said Lerner.

“The many settings in which the value of intuition is extolled — for example a job interview — may need to be reassessed with a more nuanced perspective,” she said.

The study was published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

Source: American Psychological Association

Should You Trust Your Gut or Carefully Analyze the Situation?

Janice Wood

Janice Wood is a long-time writer and editor who began working at a daily newspaper before graduating from college. She has worked at a variety of newspapers, magazines and websites, covering everything from aviation to finance to healthcare.

APA Reference
Wood, J. (2018). Should You Trust Your Gut or Carefully Analyze the Situation?. Psych Central. Retrieved on September 28, 2020, from
Scientifically Reviewed
Last updated: 8 Aug 2018 (Originally: 23 Jul 2016)
Last reviewed: By a member of our scientific advisory board on 8 Aug 2018
Published on Psych All rights reserved.