A new study finds that if we’re ever going to achieve a healthy compromise in politics, people with opposing viewpoints need to get to know one another. But this is going to be a tough sell, because people tend to live and work among like-minded people, as this enhances individual well-being.
In fact, according to the findings, living around people with opposing political viewpoints can be quite unappealing — it affects your ability to form close relationships and may even change your personality.
The findings could help explain why so many Americans are moving to areas that suit them politically, further segregating the nation into “red” and “blue” states, said Dr. William Chopik, Michigan State University (MSU) assistant professor of psychology.
And while living among folks of common ideology may reduce conflict and promote individual well-being, it also could be stifling healthy political conversation, added Chopik, who was named one of Forbes’ “30 Under 30” for Science in 2016.
“You might be happier if you’re a conservative and you move to a stereotypical conservative place, or a liberal to a liberal one, but maybe that’s one of the reasons we see all the deadlock and polarization along party lines,” Chopik said. “If you never live among people you disagree with, how does compromise happen?”
The researchers analyzed national survey data of 19,162 people that included participants’ political orientation, ideological climate, and personality measures such as anxiety and avoidance (survey items include “I try to avoid getting too close to others” and “I sometimes try to understand my friends better by imagining how things look from their perspective”).
According to the study, being the political black sheep in an area has a real psychological effect on people. These political “misfits” have a hard time depending on and accepting the viewpoints of others. Further, rather than assimilate or alter their dispositions to be more similar to their neighbors, they tend to withdraw from relationships.
“Because living among politically dissimilar others is associated with a reduced sense of belonging, ideological misfits may feel as though they cannot reliably depend on the people around them,” said the researchers.
In the current political climate, Chopik said it’s not uncommon for conservatives not to know any Hillary Clinton supporters, or for liberals not to know any Donald Trump supporters. This may be at least partly the result of political segregation.
“Obviously, Trump supporters exist, and Clinton supporters exist, but people are choosing an environment where the other side doesn’t exist,” Chopik said. “As people continue segregating themselves into geographic areas according to political ideology, it’s important to understand the psychological states of the individuals living in these discordant communities.”
The study is published online in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science.
Source: Michigan State University