When Depressed, It’s Sometimes Hard to Hear Emotion
Background noise can interfere with understanding what someone is saying, and new research suggests that depressed people find it harder to hear any kind of emotional speech in such situations — not just negatively tinged speech.
“A lot of research has suggested that these people with elevated depression symptoms have a bias towards negative perception of information in this kind of environment,” said researcher Zilong Xie, a graduate student at the University of Texas at Austin.
Investigators explain that when a listener has difficulty understanding someone else’s speech, the source of disruption can be placed into one of two categories: energetic masking or informational masking.
In energetic masking, sounds from peripheral sources such as construction sites or passing airplanes interfere with speech perception. In informational masking, the interference comes from linguistic and cognitive sources, such as the background din of human conversation.
Interestingly, informational masking tends to place greater stress on executive function than does energetic masking. This means a cocktail party, or a lecture hall, can become a potentially detaching experience.
The science of psychoacoustics identifies five basic types of emotional speech: angry, fearful, happy, sad, and neutral.
“A lot of studies published in JASA [The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America] only look at neutral speech, speech without emotive content,” Xie said.
“If we want to fully understand what’s going on with speech perception, particularly in a multi-tonal condition, which very often happens in our daily lives, we need to look at those kinds of emotional speech.”
From previous studies, Xie and his colleagues predicted that the bias of people with elevated signs of depression towards remembering sad information might lead them to more easily detect negative information in these environments.
To test their hypothesis, the researchers recruited students with either low or elevated symptoms of depression to gauge their speech perception in the presence of either energetic masking or informational masking.
In the study, the researchers tested the volunteers’ ability to perceive speech in various conditions by having them listen to a recording of a target sentence featuring one of the five types of emotional speech mixed with noise.
The students then typed out the target sentence, which was later compared with the actual sentences, to determine how accurately they heard it. The test was performed fifty times with each volunteer, covering ten unique sentences of each emotional type.
“We found that people with elevated depression symptoms are generally poorer at hearing all types of emotional speech relative to people with low depression symptoms,” Xie said.
Researchers were surprised that the more depressed subjects did not better understand negative sentences conveyed in information masking environments than those without those symptoms. They performed poorly, regardless of the emotional content of the sentences.
However, both groups performed comparably when the sentences were read to them in energetic masking conditions.
Xie and his colleagues presented their findings at the 169th meeting of the Acoustical Society of America (ASA).
Nauert PhD, R. (2015). When Depressed, It’s Sometimes Hard to Hear Emotion. Psych Central. Retrieved on March 20, 2018, from https://psychcentral.com/news/2015/05/26/when-depressed-all-emotional-speech-is-sad/84972.html