According to Rob Gray, Ph.D, author of a new article in Current Directions in Psychological Science, paying too much attention to what you’re doing can ruin performance.
“We think when you’re under pressure, that your attention goes inward naturally. Suddenly it means so much, you want to make sure everything’s working properly,” says Gray, of the University of Birmingham.
“And that is exactly when things go wrong. Something about paying attention to what you’re doing makes it not work right.”
Everyone knows that they should just relax and do their usual thing, but it’s not very helpful to tell someone to just relax.
The goal for psychological scientists, Gray said, is to figure out what actually happens when someone starts paying too much attention to their body.
“Focusing on what you’re doing makes you mess up, but why? How do your movements change? How can we focus on correcting those issues instead of telling you to stop trying so hard?”
Gray has found that baseball players under pressure have fewer hits because their swing varies more under pressure than at normal times.
Other researchers have found that climbers move less fluidly when they’re higher up on a wall than when they’re near the ground, which suggests that their joints move less freely when they’re more anxious.
Pressure often causes certain fundamentals to go wrong—changing the angle of the club head when putting or throwing with more force. If those things can be identified, a coach could work on the particular problems.
One way to do it might be with analogies, Gray said. For example, a golfer who grips the club too tight when she’s nervous might benefit from an instruction like “imagine you have an open tube of toothpaste between your hands and the contents must not be pushed out.”
This would both address the problem and divert attention away from how well she’s doing.