Donald Johnson on ECT
Donald Johnson presented to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration Neurological Devices Panel examining the reclassification of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) devices on January 27, 2011. These are his remarks as published in the public record of the meeting.
I thank you for this opportunity. Forgive me my emotion. I was here at the FDA in 1985 and testified, and later on that year, the National Institutes of Health, the National Institute of Mental Health, had a two-day consensus conference on electroconvulsive therapy.
I don’t have a memory. I don’t know if it’s because I argued with a psychiatrist and he dumped me in the locked ward and shocked me five times. I became violent. I tore my nails off grabbing onto the door, and he said after five times, he says, sometimes they don’t help people.
The way I got in there was arguing with him. I had trouble with headaches. I’ve learned since then it’s because I was deprived of coffee. I had a drunken acting first sergeant that had confined me to quarters, and he got away with it, and I had headaches and I complained. So I’m psychiatrically labeled. But I became a physics teacher, and I have degrees in mathematics and physics for Carver Arnum Research (ph.) and I decided to go teaching physics.
I would ask any of these professionals here for the physics. You know, they say physics is an example. A little physics to see if there’s any — this is high school physics. High school physics. If I had a 15-pound baby, talking about 200 joules, and when they talk about low treatments, every one of you that’s involved in ECT knows that if they don’t make a grand mal seizure, it doesn’t count. Give it again. Turn up the voltage. All right. 200 joules. How high would I have to drop a 15-pound baby to have the equivalent of one shock treatment? All you professionals here. How high would I have to drop a 15-pound baby to have the same energy or how many pistol slugs would I have to shoot into its brain? This is just mechanical equivalence, high school physics. Anybody?
A joule is the energy of one kilogram being lifted a tenth of a meter. It’s equivalent to dropping a baby from a 10-foot high building.
At the 1985 National Institutes of Health conference, I gave them the Winchester ballistics sheet from Winchester and a Thymatron electroconvulsive device showing the energy equivalent to three pistol slugs to the head.
Now, they use autism to justify it and use depression. Did anybody watch the BBC with the G-20 last month? Obama was in South Korea, and BBC had a little spot on it, “The Devastated Seoul,” now one of the most thriving affluent societies, and they said how much appreciation. They went back and said, “But there’s a problem.” They’ve got the highest suicide rate in the world. Between the ages of 10 and 40, the major cause of death now is suicide in Korea. Is it because they need a shock treatment? It wasn’t like that before the war? Affluence.