Home » Blog » Can a Good Marriage Have Problems?

Can a Good Marriage Have Problems?

If your partner says, “We have a problem,” does your chest tighten? Do you forget to breathe? What goes through your mind? “A problem! Aggh! Does that mean he (or she) will leave me? Is our relationship doomed?” Do you imagine that something is terribly wrong with the two of you as a couple and maybe impossible to fix? If this sounds like you, you are probably being duped by a harmful marriage myth: A good marriage has no problems.

Conflict exists in any marriage. Our challenge is to deal with differences constructively.

Whether because of the fairy tales we grew up with or because schools teach virtually nothing about the realities of marriage, many people think that in a good marriage a couple is not supposed to have any problems. They will pretend all is rosy until the stress of keeping their feelings inside builds to the point where it comes out harmfully.

Here are a few signs that may indicate you are ignoring a relationship issue: Your sex life is not good. Your child is too quiet or too aggressive. You think your partner doesn’t love you. One of you is depressed, angry, or jumpy. You or your partner is drinking, eating, or gambling excessively.

Each of us has wants and needs — which don’t always mesh with those of our mate. When we try to ignore what keeps us upset for too long, it can erupt like a volcano. Your particular challenge may concern intimacy, parenting, sex, money, in-laws, work, or something else. Do not wait to deal with anything that puts your relationship at risk.

Marriage meetings, as described step by step in my book, Marriage Meetings for Lasting Love, provide a safe, sure time for a gentle, loosely structured conversation during which you both get to talk about what’s on your minds. You get to reconnect with each other lovingly, to nurture yourselves and your relationship. You maintain the good feelings by dealing with small issues before they grow into big ones.

The Potential for Conflict Exists Everywhere

Marriage and relationship educator Ellen Kreidman, PhD, gives a simple example to show that potential for conflict exists in any marriage. She states that in the bathroom one spouse wants the toilet paper to unroll from the top; the other wants it to unroll from the bottom. One leaves the toilet seat up; the other wants it down; one likes a sparkling-clean sink; the other leaves hairs or specks of makeup in it. One likes the door open; the other insists on privacy, and so on. If you’re thinking separate bathrooms, I’m with you! But that is not always possible. Still, by being creative and resourceful, you can often come up with ways to lessen annoyances.

The Risk of Concealing Differences

Lilly and Jonathan illustrate the danger of taking too long to identify and deal with a sensitive issue. Still childless after eight years of marriage, they finally adopted a baby girl. When Lilly first met Jonathan, she admired his take-charge manner. She felt protected by him. Soft-spoken and diplomatic, she acquiesced to him on most matters. Lilly’s parents had fought a lot and eventually divorced. She didn’t want this to happen to her. She believed it was important to go along with her husband on most matters in order to keep the peace.

Before they became parents, Jonathan encouraged Lilly to give up her career as a hospital nurse to stay home with their child at least until kindergarten. Lilly thought this was a small price to pay for realizing her dream of motherhood. She squelched her doubts about giving up the work she loved. She told herself that doing what her husband wanted was the right thing to do.

After two years at home, Lilly thought she would lose her mind. She loved her little girl, but she sorely missed the hustle and bustle of her hospital work, interacting with colleagues, and caring for patients. She also missed the salary, which she had been free to spend as she chose. Now when Jonathan objected to a small purchase she made, he justified his stance by saying, “I’m the breadwinner.” Lilly felt her chest tighten at such times. Wanting to keep the peace, she would say, “I’ll take it back.”

Lilly Pretends All is Well until it is too Late

In public, Lilly played the part of a smiling, contented wife and mother. Privately, she began to feel distant from her husband. She lost interest in sex. She resented him but said nothing. She felt ignored and invisible — until she served a stunned Jonathan with divorce papers.

Is Jonathan a villain? Lilly had shared none of her frustration with him. Should Jonathan have read her mind? Either partner might have saved their marriage by initiating an honest conversation. Jonathan could have asked his wife whether something other than her “headaches” was causing her to withdraw sexually. She could have told him about her unhappiness and said what she really wanted, even if she felt selfish or guilty.

This couple might then have found ways to compromise, perhaps by agreeing that she would return to work part-time. Lilly might have suggested to Jonathan that it would be fair for each of them to have a certain amount of money to spend with no questions asked, regardless of who earned it. By talking it out with honesty and mutual respect, they might well have created a way for practical solutions to emerge, for trust to grow, and for the return of emotional and physical intimacy.

All intimate relationships have issues. Deal with them constructively, and you will grow personally and strengthen your bond. By adapting a more realistic viewpoint about marriage you will be able to use effective techniques for creating a union that fulfills you emotionally and spiritually as well as physically and materially.

This article is adapted from the chapter, “Debunking Marriage Myths,” in the book, Marriage Meetings for Lasting Love; 30 Minutes a Week to the Relationship You’ve Always Wanted (New World Library).

Unhappy couple photo available from Shutterstock

Can a Good Marriage Have Problems?

This article features affiliate links to, where a small commission is paid to Psych Central if a book is purchased. Thank you for your support of Psych Central!

Marcia Naomi Berger, MSW, LCSW

Marcia Naomi Berger, MSW, LCSW, author of Marriage Meetings for Lasting Love: 30 Minutes a Week to the Relationship You’ve Always Wanted (New World Library, 2014, audiobook, 2020), has a private psychotherapy practice in San Rafael, California. She offers and workshops for couples and singles, and continuing education classes for therapists at NASW conferences and online. She has taught also at the UCSF School of Medicine, UC Berkeley Extension, and Alliant International University. A former executive director of a family service agency, she earlier held senior level positions in child welfare, alcoholism treatment, and psychiatry.

No comments yet... View Comments / Leave a Comment
APA Reference
Berger, M. (2018). Can a Good Marriage Have Problems?. Psych Central. Retrieved on December 1, 2020, from
Scientifically Reviewed
Last updated: 8 Jul 2018 (Originally: 8 Aug 2015)
Last reviewed: By a member of our scientific advisory board on 8 Jul 2018
Published on Psych All rights reserved.