advertisement
Home » Ask the Therapist » Our Personal Space Is Invaded by Sister-In-Law

Our Personal Space Is Invaded by Sister-In-Law

Asked by on with 1 answer:

From an adult woman in Australia: Hello, i am from indian background where cultural background and family relationships are bit different from western world. however we live in western world. My problem is that my sister in law come to our home almost every weekend with her husband and sometimes visit very late in night around 10-10:30 as well.

the problem is my husband don’t see issue in this because she is his elder sister and very dear to him. my younger unmarried sister lives with us as well but our personal space is not invaded with her presence. we can do whatever and whenever even my sister is at home but everything stops when his sister and brother in law comes over.

No matter what time they come home they eat as well. they even opens my fridge and take fruit or food out and help themselves. i don’t like when do such things. his sister sometimes says very selfish and mean things to me indirectly but i can’t do anything. Most of the time my husband knows and notices everything but he says he cannot do anything. he even says to me he has to see his sister face once a week.

my husband is very caring and nice to me but whenever i have talked to him about this issue he becomes very defensive towards her and we argue alot. our relationship is affecting alot because of this. Another issue is that Me and my husband only got weekend to spend time with each other. Weekdays we hardly see each other because of job timing.

Am i expecting from him too much? how i can explain him that it is affecting me alot and our relationship. we are not invited to her place and my husband would also not go there.  how to resolve this issue?  i am very depressed because of this. i dont mind her coming to our place but it should be at least once in a month and specific time of the day. please help.

Our Personal Space Is Invaded by Sister-In-Law

Answered by on -

A.

Thank you for writing. This is a very complicated situation. I have more questions than answers. Why does your husband need to see his sister once a week? What is going on that he is prioritizing time with his sister on weekends when it is the only time the two of you have together? Why won’t your husband visit his sister’s home? Do the two of you come from such different backgrounds that you have entirely different expectations of marriage?

I don’t think it is expecting too much to want some answers. As I think you know, your main problem is with your relationship with your husband, not with his sister. You and your husband have a very basic and painful (to you) difference of opinion about where his loyalties should be and how much his family should be involved in your marriage.

In western culture, his sister would be seen as violating marital boundaries and your husband would be seen as having trouble shifting his primary alliance from his family of origin to his marriage. I don’t know anything about the expectation of your home country so I can’t comment on that. But the difference between the two may be at the center of your troubles.

What I can comment on is that not coming to agreement about appropriate boundaries could seriously erode your marriage. Your feelings of depression and discouragement are a sign that things are not going at all well.

This cannot be seen as a matter of who wins and who loses an argument. Right now, your marriage is what is losing. If the two of you are to save it and deepen it, it is essential that you work together to decide on how to manage his relationship with his sister. You are offering a compromise of once a month — which he is rejecting. Is he willing to budge at all? If not, it’s important for the two of you to talk about why. Understanding the problem is half the journey to coming to a solution.

If the two of you can’t talk about this reasonably and without getting defensive and angry, I do suggest you see a couples counselor to help you work it out. A couples counselor can provide a safe place for you both to express your feelings and to learn ways to navigate conflicts like this one.

I wish you well.
Dr. Marie

Our Personal Space Is Invaded by Sister-In-Law

Dr. Marie Hartwell-Walker

Dr. Marie is licensed as both a psychologist and marriage and family counselor. She specializes in couples and family therapy and parent education. Follow her on Facebook or Twitter.

APA Reference
Hartwell-Walker, D. (2019). Our Personal Space Is Invaded by Sister-In-Law. Psych Central. Retrieved on December 15, 2019, from https://psychcentral.com/ask-the-therapist/2019/12/01/our-personal-space-is-invaded-by-sister-in-law/
Scientifically Reviewed
Last updated: 29 Nov 2019 (Originally: 1 Dec 2019)
Last reviewed: By a member of our scientific advisory board on 29 Nov 2019
Published on Psych Central.com. All rights reserved.