Home » Ask the Therapist » How Do We Confront Our Eldest Son about Abusing His Siblings?

How Do We Confront Our Eldest Son about Abusing His Siblings?

Asked by on with 1 answer:

There has been an ongoing issue between our 3 sons.  The eldest along with his wife & daughter live with us and can’t seem to get on their feet after losing their son to SIDS 6 years ago.  They have been with us 3 years.  My middle son won’t talk to us or let us see or grandson, a talks about all this violence & stuff that we have no clue about!  My youngest, 26 y/o has finally broken the silence!  A real shocker as I have been asking all along!  Our eldest sodomized him at 4 years old in front of the middle son!  The eldest was probably 10 years old!  My middle was 5 years old.  OMG!!!  I don’t know what to do!!  He kept them in fear for years doing things to them!  Not just this kind of stuff!  He threatened with their lives!!  I worked shift work and my husband worked days & he told me to get them out of the babysitters because there was funny stuff going on there, so we did.  My youngest said yeah, so he could do it to us!  But about a year ago, my eldest told me that my nephew molested him, I didn’t get the details I was shocked, then later, my  nephew tells his mom & I his teacher molested him in kindergarten!  He is a few years older than my eldest son.  Where do I start to get my sons help?  I am afraid my eldest will hurt/kill himself because he has talked about it before!

How Do We Confront Our Eldest Son about Abusing His Siblings?

Answered by on -


A: I’m so sorry that you are all going through this. How tragic that basically everyone involved was abused or in fear of abuse. Unfortunately, this pattern is fairly common until someone breaks the silence and adults can intervene. In this case, you are only finding out now that all your children are already adults. The complicating factor is that they are all adults and responsible for themselves now. Of course as their mother you want to help, and they probably still look to you for help and guidance, but ultimately it is their responsibility to get help for themselves.

If you haven’t already, I would educate yourself on the effects of sibling abuse and sexual abuse so that you more fully understand what all your sons (and nephew) are going through. Here’s a good place to start:

Next, I would recommend finding a family therapist who also has training in abuse and trauma. You and your husband might want to meet with the therapist first to give some background, but then I would try to arrange some family therapy sessions with all your sons attending. Obviously you may encounter resistance from some or all of your children. I would take the approach that you are recognizing the pain they are feeling and doing what you can to help now. If they won’t agree to meet together, you could meet with them one at a time with the therapist with the goal of breaking the silence, acknowledging what happened and finding a respectful (and safe) way to move forward as a family.

However, I feel compelled to say that you may need to be prepared for the fact that the wounds may be too deep and have been present for too long to fully mend. It may be the case that you will have to have separate relationships with them all, i.e. making different plans for holiday events. Furthermore, if they won’t attend therapy at all, it may still be helpful for you and your husband.

Finally, I am so sorry that your son and his wife lost a child. It is truly a devastating experience to go through, but it is not your responsibility to support them for life. Some people never do the work required to support themselves as long as someone else is willing to do it for them. It may be time for some tough love, and yet again, something a therapist can help you with. I wish you all the best and hope that some deep healing can take place.


Dr. Holly Counts

How Do We Confront Our Eldest Son about Abusing His Siblings?

Therapists live, online right now, from BetterHelp:

Holly Counts, Psy.D.

Dr. Holly Counts is a licensed Clinical Psychologist. She utilizes a mind, body and spirit approach to healing. Dr. Counts received her Bachelor’s degree in Psychology from Wright State University and her Masters and Doctoral degrees in Clinical Psychology from Nova Southeastern University. Dr. Counts has worked in a variety of settings and has specialized in trauma and abuse, relationship issues, health psychology, women’s issues, adolescence, GLBT, life transitions and grief counseling. She has specialty training in guided imagery, EMDR, EFT, hypnosis and using intuition to heal. Her current passion involves integrating holistic and alternative approaches to health and healing with psychology.

APA Reference
Counts, H. (2018). How Do We Confront Our Eldest Son about Abusing His Siblings?. Psych Central. Retrieved on November 30, 2020, from
Scientifically Reviewed
Last updated: 8 May 2018 (Originally: 25 Jul 2014)
Last reviewed: By a member of our scientific advisory board on 8 May 2018
Published on Psych All rights reserved.