AIDS debate launches Lancet podcast

The Lancet launches its podcast with a debate that took place at the International AIDS conference in Toronto, Canada yesterday.

Moderated by Dr Richard Horton, Editor of The Lancet, the debate posed the question: Is scaling up the response to the HIV epidemic doing more good than harm?

Speaking for the motion:
Mark Dybul (Global AIDS co-ordinator for the Presidents Emergency Programme for HIV/AIDS Relief; PEPFAR)
David Wilson (The World Bank)

Speaking against the motion:
David Barr (Director of the Collaborative Fund for HIV Treatment Preparedness at the Tides Foundation)
Vineeta Gupta (Director of the Stop HIV/AIDS in India Initiative)

Over 50 scientists, activists, and public health experts attended the debate. At the beginning of the session 48 members of the audience were for the motion, 4 against, and 4 abstained. At the end of the debate there were 43 people for the motion, 2 against, and 11 abstainers.


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Wednesday August 16, 2006.

To listen to an edited version of the debate go to

To subscribe to The Lancet podcast cut and paste this URL into iTunes or other podcast aggregator:

The Lancet press office
T) +44 (0) 207 424 4949/4249
[email protected]

Notes to editors
The Lancet podcast is registered on iTunes, for further information visit:

You can give feedback on the podcast at [email protected]

Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 21 Feb 2009
    Published on All rights reserved.