Greater risk of cancer deaths and procedure-related deaths
ORLANDO (November 1, 2004) -- Analyses of virtual colonoscopy found both procedure-related mortality and cancer deaths were higher compared to complete (i.e., traditional) colonoscopy, according to findings presented today at the 69th Annual Scientific Meeting of the American College of Gastroenterology (ACG). The analyses, conducted by researchers from Oregon Health and Science University and the Portland VA Medical Center, found that virtual colonoscopy, a test for colorectal cancer that relies on a CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis, carries significant radiation exposure and is less likely to detect cancer or pre-cancerous growths in the colon.
Douglas Faigel, M.D. and colleagues Amnon Sonnenberg, M.D. and David A. Lieberman, M.D. looked at hypothetical cohorts of 100,000 patients undergoing either a single colonoscopy or a virtual colonoscopy at age 60. A key assumption of their decision analysis model is that one-third of patients who undergo virtual colonoscopy will need to have a follow-up colonoscopy.
The Oregon researchers examined complications and deaths per 100,000 patients. "With virtual colonoscopy, we don't avoid the risks of complications from colonoscopy such as bleeding or perforation," explains Dr. Faigel. Rather, the rate of complications for virtual colonoscopy is higher than expected because most of those follow-up colonoscopies are likely to involve the removal of polyps, which increases the likelihood of complications.
Radiation Exposure a Significant Risk
Dr. Faigel warns that virtual colonoscopy exposes normal, healthy people to significant radiation, "A CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis in virtual colonoscopy is a lot of radiation."
For this analysis he and his colleagues assumed a single CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis at age 60 carries the risk of cancer death of 1 in 4,000 and based this assumption on studies looking at cancer deaths among those exposed to radiation from atomic bombs in the 1940s. Using this assumption, the Oregon model predicts 25 radiation related deaths per 100,000 associated with virtual colonoscopy. Overall, the model attributes nine procedure-related deaths per 100,000 to traditional colonoscopy, compared to 30 deaths per 100,000 for virtual colonoscopy, including the 25 deaths related to radiation and five procedure-related deaths.
Deaths Attributed to Missed Cancers
The model determined there were 286 colorectal cancer deaths per 100,000 with virtual colonoscopy, compared to 220 per 100,000 with conventional colonoscopy. Dr. Faigel attributes this higher rate of mortality for virtual colonoscopy to declining sensitivity when the two tests are performed. In the model, the researchers assumed a rate of sensitivity for both virtual colonoscopy and traditional colonoscopy of 90 percent. Therefore, in an exam 10 percent of significant lesions (large polyps or cancers) will be missed. "These assumptions are a bit high for virtual colonoscopy and actually understate the sensitivity for traditional colonoscopy which usually would exceed 90 percent," explains Dr. Faigel. "In our model, if a patient had a virtual colonoscopy first and then a conventional colonoscopy, the sensitivity declines to about 81 percent. That's where we found greater colorectal cancer deaths for virtual colonoscopy than with conventional colonoscopy alone."
Information About Colonoscopy and Virtual Colonoscopy from ACG
The four largest studies of virtual colonoscopy have been published in the last year, and three of the four studies showed very poor results for virtual colonoscopy compared to colonoscopy. Only a study by Pickhardt et al. showed results for virtual colonoscopy comparable to complete colonoscopy, and the reasons for the discrepancies between studies remain uncertain. No guideline group has yet endorsed virtual colonoscopy as appropriate for colorectal cancer screening. Colonoscopy remains the most sensitive test available for detection of colorectal and cancer.
The questions raised by recent studies underscore the importance of colonoscopy being performed by skilled practitioners. According to the American College of Gastroenterology, patients undergoing colonoscopy should identify doctors who have substantial experience having performed large numbers of endoscopies, usually evidenced by their having received training in gastroenterology fellowship or surgical residency programs.
Source: Eurekalert & othersLast reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 21 Feb 2009
Published on PsychCentral.com. All rights reserved.
Success is the ability to go from one failure to another with no loss of enthusiasm.
~ Winston Churchill