Should We Treat Depression Differently for Lefties?
New research suggests the way we use our hands may determine how emotions are organized in our brains. If this presumption is correct, scientists may need to review the method by which neural stimulation is administered to individuals with severe depression.
Psychologists Geoffrey Brookshire and Dr. Daniel Casasanto of The New School for Social Research have published their study in the journal PLoS ONE.
Researchers have long considered motivation, or the drive to approach or withdraw from physical and social stimuli, as the basic building block of human emotion.
Scientists have also operated on the premise that motivation is computed mainly in the left hemisphere of the brain, and withdraw motivation in the right hemisphere.
In the new study, Brookshire and Casasanto’s challenge this idea, as they determine a well-established pattern of brain activity, found across dozens of studies in right-handers, completely reverses in left-handers.
The researchers used electroencepahlography (EEG) to compare activity in participants’ right and left hemispheres during rest. After having their brain waves measured, participants completed a survey measuring their level of approach motivation, a core aspect of our personalities.
In right-handers, stronger approach motivation was associated with greater activity in the left hemisphere than the right, consistent with previous studies. Left-handers showed the opposite pattern: approach motivation was associated with greater activity in the right hemisphere than the left.
However, most cognitive functions do not reverse with handedness. Language, for example, is mainly in the left hemisphere for the majority of right- and left-handers.
Nevertheless, the finding of contralateral approach motivation activity was not unexpected.
“We predicted this hemispheric reversal because we observed that people tend to use different hands to perform approach- and avoidance-related actions,” says Casasanto.
Approach actions are often performed with the dominant hand, and avoidance actions with the non-dominant hand.
“Approach motivation is computed by the hemisphere that controls the right hand in right-handers, and by the hemisphere that controls the left hand in left-handers,” says Casasanto.
“We don’t think this is a coincidence. Neural circuits for motivation may be functionally related to circuits that control hand actions – emotion may be built upon neural circuits for action, in evolutionary or developmental time.”
The authors caution that these data show a correlation between emotional motivation and motor control, and that further studies are needed to establish a causal link.
Investigators believe the findings are important because of the current method to treat depression and anxiety with neural stimulation. Currently, brain stimulation is used to increase neural activity in the patient’s left hemisphere, long believed to the ‘approach hemisphere.”
“Given what we show here,” says Brookshire, “this treatment, which helps right-handers, may be detrimental to left-handers — the exact opposite of what they need.” The discovery that approach motivation reverses with handedness may lead to safer, more effective neural therapies for left-handers, according to Brookshire, “it’s something we’re investigating now.”
Nauert PhD, R. (2012). Should We Treat Depression Differently for Lefties?. Psych Central. Retrieved on February 9, 2016, from http://psychcentral.com/news/2012/05/03/should-we-treat-depression-differently-for-lefties/38171.html