This book sat on my desk for five weeks, glaring at me and daring me to read it. I didn’t want to. I was depressed and didn’t want to read about someone else’s troubles. Nevertheless, I finally forced myself to do so, and I’m glad I did. Her up-and-down story has a nice ending and reinforces the idea that there’s hope in perseverance.
First off, Mrs. Thody’s book is not a well-researched treatise on bipolar disorder. It’s not designed to do much in the way of education, and reading it won’t point you to the perfect drug for controlling bipolar disorder.
Instead, Thody designed her book to give hope. Mrs. Thody wants to show that despite problems with bipolar disorder, you can maintain a functional, happy life. She does this with a mini-biography, and she does the job well. If you, or someone you know has bipolar disorder and hasn’t read a lot about the disease, this would be a good first book — it shows that with hope there’s perseverance.
There’s a famous biography of a manic depressive called An Unquiet Mind by Kay Jamison Redfield. (Redfield’s story is good and anyone interested in bipolar disorder should read her book.) Thody’s story doesn’t have as many retrospectively almost-funny stories in it as Kay Jamison Redfield’s story. Thody never bought twelve snakebite kits or anything amusing like that.
I think Thody’s highs were different from Redfield’s. Redfield’s book was a little more amusing; Thody’s is perhaps more relatable to non-bipolar people. (I mean, no one in Los Angeles needs twelve snakebite kits whereas Thody’s renting an apartment that was a little too expensive for her is more relatable. Many people do that and they don’t have mood disorders.)
Thody grew up in Canada and lives in a small town in Canada today. She lived in one house as a child, and her family moved when she was between her junior and senior year of high school. She did a year of college to be a pharmacy technician and then later went to college to be a schoolteacher. She currently teaches elementary school.
Thody had a spell of anorexia in her early teenage years. She makes it clear that she thinks adult females should not obsess about weight in front of young girls. I agree. In fact, on time on the way to my grandfather’s funeral, I chastised my sisters for talking non-stop about their diets in from of my seven-year-old daughter. They apologized, and I think they took that lesson home and are careful around their daughters. I heartily approve of Thody asking people to not obsess about weight and transferring that obsession to young girls.
Thody first experienced problems with bipolar disorder at around the age of 19 or 20. (My first problems with the disorder popped up around the age of 15. Both of those ages are “normal” for onset of the problem.)
Sometimes people ask me about bipolar disorder and the associated stuff. A common question is something like, “Do the meds make you not you?” My answer goes like this: When I’m not on my meds, if I stub my toe on the way to the shower, I’ll probably end up going back to bed and crying for two hours and never actually starting the day. When I’m on my meds, I can stub my toe and then let out a few colorful metaphors, take a shower, and get on with life. If the meds are turning me into “not me,” then I’m good with that.
While Thody wasn’t answering the med question, she did show the difference of being in a bad situation with and without the meds. When Thody’s first grandmother died, she was not on meds and depressed. She said, “The news struck me like a bullet in the heart… Why? And most importantly, why not me? I had so little to give this world…” Thody sort of attempted suicide shortly after her grandmother died and she was not medicated. When her other grandmother died, she was on her medication. Thody says, “I was very sad about this grandma dying, of course, but my life didn’t completely fall apart this time…I was in control. I had my medication, love, and hope in my life.”
In summary, if you are new to bipolar disorder and need some life stories, this is a good story. I had one personal problem with the book that most people won’t have, however. Shelley Thody is rather religious and attributes many of life’s situations to God and Devil. If you’re religious, you’ll probably appreciate that and it might even reaffirm your faith. If you’re agnostic or an atheist, it’s probably a bit over the comfort limit.
]]>Melancholy, Mania, and Miracles: My Journey With Bipolar Disorder
by Shelley Thody
WestBowPress, November 27, 2012
Paperback, 108 pages
$10.16
It’s a too-familiar story. James and Cindy have come in for couples counseling because they worry they have grown apart. With three children under the age of 12, they want to see if they can salvage their marriage. They can’t imagine breaking up the family even though they feel they are breaking up.
Cindy is tearful. When asked the last time she felt close to James, she says it was probably shortly after the youngest was born. Since then, there seems to be no time for them as a couple. She misses him. She says she loves the active, energetic household and all the kids’ activities. She loves her job. She does love James. How on earth do other people hold onto romance when there is so much to do in a day?
James, for his part, also enjoys his kids and the hubbub that comes with family life. He coaches the eldest’s soccer team on Saturday mornings and takes his two daughters to swim team practices when he can. He feels somewhat guilty that he can’t find more time to be with Cindy but resents it that she isn’t more understanding. He’s doing the best he can to do his job and be a dad. He says that other than the kids, he doesn’t think they have much in common anymore.
This marriage is drowning in parenting. What has evolved is a child-centered arrangement that is working for the kids but not for the adults. Jobs, household chores and the children’s activities have crept into every available minute of every day. The only time the couple gets to see each other alone is during the few minutes before they go to sleep, when they are exhausted. These people are great parents and effective partners in the business of being a family, but they have lost much of the connection with each other.
Though understandable, it’s still a big problem. The foundation of their family, their couple-ness, is crumbling. They don’t talk about much of anything except the kids’ issues, what house repairs have to be done or bills have to paid, and who is going where with whom. They have become less and less physically intimate. They aren’t fighting. They just don’t have much to say to each other that couldn’t be said to the babysitter or the plumber. Sadly, the kids aren’t getting to see an affectionate, involved partnership as a role model for what a relationship should be like. Instead, they are experiencing their parents as being separate and lonely.
If all this sounds familiar, know that you aren’t alone. Most families require more than one income to stay financially afloat. That means that both members of the couple are juggling schedules, chores, and childcare. Reconnecting takes a re-evaluation of priorities and making some changes. To preserve and grow their relationship, the adults need to take care of their own needs as well as their children’s.
A few simple but important changes can shift the focus from the children back to the couple – at least enough of the time to re-establish parents as loving mates.
We can only be romantic if there is time for romance. Set aside one evening a week for date night. If possible, get a sitter and go out. If you can’t afford a sitter, consider swapping off child care with a friend or starting a childcare co-op. If even that doesn’t work, stay in but put a boundary around time together. Get a movie the kids will enjoy. Set them up with popcorn and tell them they can’t bother Mom and Dad while they have dinner unless someone is bleeding or the house is on fire. Drawing a circle around a few hours a week demonstrates to the kids that the couple is important. Spending that time together gives you and your spouse time to reconnect.
In James’s and Cindy’s case, each child had three different activities outside of school. That’s a total of nine different activities times the number of hours per week each one required. We counted it up. The couple was spending almost 32 hours a week transporting and witnessing kid-events. No wonder they had no time for each other! By cutting back to two activities per kid per week, they freed up 10 hours to do other things.
To keep child care costs down, James and Cindy were often taking turns at parenting so each could pursue their own interests. It’s certainly fair. It does let each person have some time to be with his or her own friends. But if it isn’t balanced with couple time, tag-teaming can mean the couple primarily sees each other during hectic hand-offs of the kids.
It can be anything from serving on a town committee to hiking or dancing to participating in a class or club. Or you might want to find a way to spend regular adult time with adult friends. You need something to talk to each other about besides the children’s activities and whether the lawn needs mowing this weekend.
Shut down computers and outside work one-half hour to one hour prior to bedtime. Use that time as couple time. You can decompress, talk, cuddle, give each other a backrub or be sexually intimate. One-half hour may not seem like much, but the daily ritual can be an important affirmation of your caring for each other. There’s something about spending together time at the very end of the day that lends itself to closeness.
Please don’t get caught up in the idea that being a loving couple and spending time together should be spontaneous. Modern family life doesn’t allow for much spontaneity, however much we might like the idea. Couples, like gardens, appliances and friendships, take maintenance. That means some planning.
James and Cindy got a wake-up call. They were able to reconnect and to reorder their lives. Making daily space in their schedules to be close to each other helped them rediscover the many good things that brought them together in the first place.
]]>This quote, from Buddha, is one of many warm, useful sayings in Words of Love: Quotations from the Heart. From religious texts to scientists to novelists and pop icons, author Allen Klein draws on a host of sources to form this quintessential collection of wisdom on love.
With a season of graduations and weddings ahead, not to mention anniversaries and forgotten birthdays, it’d be smart to have several copies of this book on hand. There is nothing not to like about it. But as marketable as the text is for gift-giving, it’s also a great idea to keep your own copy for lonely times. Flipping through it at the beginning or end of each day can give you a little boost.
Klein is no stranger to helping people enhance their lives with earlier books like Change Your Life!: A Little Book of Big Ideas (2010), Inspiration for a Lifetime: Words of Wisdom, Delight, and Possibility (2010), Learning to Laugh When You Feel Like Crying: Embracing Life After Loss (2011), and The Art of Living Joyfully: How to be Happier Every Day of the Year (2012). I suspect that working on these earlier publications, he compiled notebooks full of good quotes.
The most helpful thing Klein does, aside from giving us 500+ great sayings, is to separate them by type. Chapters like “What is Love,” “Falling in Love,” “Mother’s Love,” “Unconditional Love,” “Loving Yourself,” and “Loving Couples” allow you to find the perfect words for any special moment where you’d like to share a meaningful thought as well as your love.
There are quotes from literary figures on inspiration: “It is love, not faith, that removes mountains” (George Sand). There are quotes from peacemakers and political leaders: “Where there is love, there is life” (Mahatma Gandhi). And there is even hope from singer and actor Cher: “If grass can grow through cement, love can find you at every time in your life.”
If you’re feeling lonely, this is an incredibly affordable way to chase away the blues. And, anyone with family and friends will appreciate this little book, even if they don’t gush when they open the gift. Pearl Bailey’s “What the world needs is more love and less paperwork” will ensure that even the most seasoned businessman will tuck this away after finding that, yes, quotations from the heart apply in all chapters of one’s life.
]]>Words of Love: Quotations from the Heart
Viva Editions, December, 2012
Paperback, 224 pages
Mother of two young kids, Molly Skyar interviews her mother, Dr. Susan Rutherford, a clinical psychologist about how to deal with a manipulative child and how your parenting decisions today may affect your child as an adult.
Dr. Rutherford: That is an interesting question, and I don’t have a definitive answer, but even very young children can see the power they can have over their parents. It’s mostly an issue of patterns.
For instance, if a 2-year-old is crying at night and his parents always pick him up and hold him when he does this, he will actually train himself to wake up to get the comfort. You could call that manipulative behavior, and maybe it is, but I confess that I’m on the fence about using that term here.
Children can learn how to get certain responses from their parents from a very young age. Typically not before 15 months, but some kids can understand this dynamic really quickly, and the parents can tell. They may feel manipulated and resent their child. In this case, they must intervene to change the dynamic. Let’s remember who’s the parent and who’s the child. As a parent, you have to set the tone for the child, and when they attempt to manipulate you, you have to be firm – loving but firm – that it is not going to work.
Supposing you have an older child. You might want to set up some limits around how often they can be on the computer. Then he or she will test you (and they will always test you) by trying to expand beyond the boundaries you have set. You should expect this. You’ll have to intervene right away and say, “Remember how we talked about this: you get to play on your computer for one-half hour a day and now you’re moving into 45 minutes. That’s not okay, and you need to put the computer away. If you can’t follow the rules, you’ll lose your time on the computer tomorrow.”
Kids will test you, and may test to see if they can manipulate you with tears or tantrums, and a parent should be ready to face these behaviors with resolve.
Molly: Are there any long-term consequences for not dealing with this type of manipulative behavior early on?
Dr. Rutherford: Yes, there can be, especially if the pattern sets in and the child learns that the way to get what he wants is to manipulate the parents. Children can actually be quite good at this. That behavior will go on and on at home, and it will expand to include other people like classmates and teachers, or other people that he comes in contact with, like coaches. Nobody likes to feel manipulated and usually people do experience a sense of being manipulated when it happens. What happens if this is left unaddressed in children is they end up forming a kind of character flaw or a negative character aspect that follows them into adulthood and really lasts forever. It’s much more difficult to change your character as an adult.
Molly: What might you see in the workplace?
Dr. Rutherford: You could see all kinds of behaviors in adults who were manipulative children, especially if a person wants to get out of doing a job. He or she might manipulate their boss or with co-workers, sometimes without fully realizing what is happening.
Manipulation can take many forms. Often, people will use shame as the tool to get what they want. They will shame other people to get them to do what they want. The other person knows something’s wrong when this happens, but they often don’t see the complete picture of what it is that is happening.
Molly: What about in relationships, like in marriages or partnerships?
Dr. Rutherford: That’s when you really see this type of character flaw show up, often on a daily basis. A manipulative person might twist things around to make her partner feel as if something is not the manipulator’s fault, and is, in fact, the partner’s fault. It makes the partner very angry and confused. This type of manipulation is often subtle, making it uncomfortably difficult to be in a relationship with someone who behaves this way.
Molly: So the manipulation is there, but it’s not that obvious.
Dr. Rutherford: Right. In children, manipulative behavior is usually pretty obvious, but as the child “perfects the art of manipulation,” they can become much more subtle, leaving people feeling uncomfortable but not quite able to put their finger on what it is that’s making them feel this way.
Molly: If you don’t deal with this type of behavior in childhood, what happens? At what age is it too late to influence character development in a child?
Dr. Rutherford: A lot of psychologists might feel that 10 to 12 years old is getting pretty late in the game to deal with character traits like this one. I don’t know exactly the cutoff age, but I do know that it gets harder and harder to manage as people move into adulthood. Certainly by the time people are in their 20s, I think it’s too late to change something like this.
Carroll has a strong history as a corporate executive, so he speaks about jobs from a viewpoint that many of us share. In another’s hands, the idea of creating a meditative environment in the office might easily come off as hazy Eastern spiritualism or drug-induced and unrealistic thinking. Here, however, the author is solidly focused on how to make your work life and your business more productive and more effective. He just wants you to enjoy the ride.
Still, Carroll’s enthusiasm for and belief in the value of what he preaches is obvious on every page — and this may make some readers uncomfortable, particularly those who prefer a more technical and less spiritual approach to work effectiveness.
One main message of the book is that life happens, and the positive or negative attributes we experience come from within us, rather than being inherent in those life events and situations. This is an old but very valuable framework. The discussion of when to let the negative things happen in a process and how to handle the stress that results from doing so is especially valuable to read.
My favorite section was Part 5: “Living a Skilled Life.” Here is where Carroll digs more deeply into the realistic integration of mindfulness, meditation, and our everyday lives. We often seek integration, but the author provides us with a short list of serious techniques to actually achieve what he has touted throughout the text.
Lest you think that the combination sounds too mystical, Carroll uses the venerable and mythic concept of American baseball to teach us a holistic approach. With baseball, he writes, “America has examined its most prized values of competition, fair play, and teamwork. Here also America has had to confront its most profound shortcomings of racism, hero workshop, fraud, and sexism.” The sport and its complex history, he tells us, act as a mirror, revealing a host of issues in one fell swoop.
Throughout the book, Carroll talks about the presence of conflict in our lives. Rather than reduce the conflict, Carroll counsels us to become comfortable with conflict through depersonalization and context awareness. Even if you were to read only those sections of the book where he focuses on how to deal with conflict, you would receive more than your money’s worth in solid and useful advice.
The one thing I found slightly off-putting about Fearless at Work was the use of many Buddhist terms throughout. While the author uses them to illustrate various mental strategies and meditation techniques, as a reader, I found them somewhat distracting. That this is the most negative thing I found speaks well of the style, content, and value of the book.
One especially nice aspect is that you do not have to read the book in a linear fashion. Carroll encourages us to “randomly” select specific areas after reading the initial section. As he says, “permit your natural curiosity to engage the situation as it unfolds.”
If your “natural curiosity” has been piqued by this, I can recommend that you spend some time with this gentle author and learn about how to bring mindfulness more fully into your life. If you are uncomfortable with the idea of examining the spiritual side of your approach to work, ask yourself why, and still consider using this book to begin a journey of self-discovery. Even if it feels difficult at first, it’s a journey worth taking.
]]>Fearless at Work: Timeless Teachings for Awakening Confidence, Resilience, and Creativity in the Face of Life’s Demands Shambhala, November, 2012
Paperback, 304 pages
$16.95
I’m probably not alone in claiming that the subject of death makes me uncomfortable and kind of fearful.
Life simply does not last; however, we of course can still find enjoyment while we are here. And on a smaller scale, life’s changes, those shifts in relationships or experiences on your journey, imply impermanence too. Yet, even though there is impermanence in life, does it mean we can’t revel or stand still in our joys? I’d like to advocate that we can still savor in spite of change, or even the looming possibility of change.
Positive psychologist Sonja Lyubomirsky discusses the concept of savoring in her text, The How of Happiness: A New Approach to Getting the Life You Want.
“Researchers define savoring as any thoughts or behaviors capable of ‘generating, intensifying, and prolonging enjoyment,’” Lyubomirsky notes. She even proposes that nostalgic trips down memory lane or fantasizing about anticipated events have their value. “Whether it involves a focus on the long ago, the present moment, or future times, the habit of savoring has been shown in empirical research to be related to intense and frequent happiness.”
Lyubomirksy recommends “celebrating good news” — allowing others to bask in your accomplishments and successes has been noted to heighten well-being and positive emotions. “Try to enjoy the occasion to the fullest. Passing on and rejoicing in good news leads you to relish and soak up the present moment, as well as to foster connections with others.”
Being open to “beauty and excellence” is another mechanism that induces savoring. Positive psychologists suggest that those who are mindful of surrounding beauty and wonder are more able to discover “joy, meaning, and profound connections in their lives.”
I’d even propose that if you absorb these ‘living in the moment’ instances with someone else (let’s say someone who’s close to you), perhaps a deeper bond in your relationship would be forged as that special memory is created. Strolling through a park with purple tulips in bloom, the sun in the sky radiating warmth, and a light breeze — the kind that is found on a perfect spring day – could be a snapshot (albeit a romantic one) definitely worth capturing.
Lyubomirsky also discusses savoring the past via reminiscing with family and friends:
“You might make a pilgrimage together to a meaningful place from your past or flip through a scrapbook or yearbook together. You might listen (or sing along) to a piece of music associated with a particular memory.”
Researchers reason that by triggering remembrance of the past, you’re producing engaging reminiscence to revisit pleasurable times. Research further concluded that reminiscing with others ignites “abundant positive emotions such as joy, accomplishment, amusement, contentment, and pride.”
Interestingly enough, and as the fates would have it, I stumbled across Haiku Kwon’s recent remarkable post while fleshing out ideas for this article. In her piece, Kwon conveys her fear of loss (after a series of unexpected deaths and broken relationships), and how that has served as a roadblock in preventing her from cherishing the current relationships she does have; I’m sure many can relate to that notion.
“Let’s fill this time we have now with all that we are instead of fighting for more and never actually doing anything with it. It’s like collecting a bunch of empty jars, but never putting anything in them.”
She rationalizes that by sifting through the mere potential of loss, we miss out on the lessons each experience offers, along with elements of happiness that are embedded within. Impermanence can be a difficult concept to grasp, and changes (big or small) could be unsettling or bittersweet. Savoring allows us to fixate on positivity while we still can.
“No matter what’s going on in your life, your life is a miracle. Right. This. Second,” Kwon writes. “Your living is an amazing orchestration of a billion and one complex systems that enables you to breathe, to think, to have a heartbeat, to learn, to grow, and to love.”
]]>Dubbed Confessions of a Worrywart: Husbands, Lovers, Mothers, and Others, and featuring such colorful chapter titles as “Shrinks are Like Boyfriends Who Can’t Dump You,” “Saving E-Mail, Saving Voicemail,” and “In Search of Grief,” Orlins’s story weaves through her life in rough chronological fashion. We learn of her kindergarten crush; her 20s as a single woman in Washington, D.C.; her 18-year marriage, which included stints of living in China and also produced three kids; her divorce; the loss of her parents; and, eventually, her life as an active and happily-independent divorcee with grown daughters.
Her writing is candid, vibrant, funny, and touching. Even so, I found myself reading more slowly than usual, simply because her stories were so evocative that they prompted near-constant daydreams, in which I’d remember similar personal incidents and ponder my reactions and feelings. I found myself alternately nodding along with recognition and recoiling in shock. As a woman in the same age range as Susan’s daughters (I feel I know Orlins so well by now that I can’t help but think of her as “Susan”), I can recognize that some things have stayed the same since the previous generation, but that, thankfully, others have changed drastically.
In the aforementioned “Shrinks” chapter, for instance, which spans 1967-1976, Orlins recalls snippets of her interactions with the various therapists she saw in her 20s. I cringed through her entire account of Dr. Miller. She begins, “When I walked into his office for my initial consultation, he hugged me — too long and too hard. As I unfolded the story of my life, he kept interrupting to tell me about his amorous triumphs” — and as I read I realized that my lip was curling back in distaste.
By the time she describes how Dr. Miller fell asleep in one session and later invited her to join a “nude group session,” which she declined (thank god!), as well as to try hypnosis, which she accepted (oh god, no, Susan!), I was completely keyed up, imagining being placed in those situations by a (male) therapist myself. I could not understand the sanguine manner by which she documented what seems to me outrageously unprofessional behavior. Perhaps we can chalk this up to “Wow, we’ve come a long way.”
But at many points in her story, I found myself chortling or nodding along in recognition. Early in the book, Orlins describes choosing her college major and minor based not on her passions, but on what she got her best grades in, and what would most likely lead to a job. She says, “…my father insisted I have something to fall back on. There was always this falling back, a requirement to stockpile safety nets, as if it were unthinkable to surge through life upright or tilting forward.” I loved her phrasing there, and empathized with her situation completely. Will that dynamic between parents and children ever change?
Likewise, on page 227 I groaned aloud at both the author and myself when I read this reference to a man she was seeing: “As with the no-soap, I quickly dismissed anything about his looks that detracted from my interest; I wanted to be gaga over him.” That hit a little close to home. I’d venture that many, many women identify with that tendency to want to want a partner more than one actually does want him, and to ignore the little twinges of misgiving.
No matter if I identified with her feelings or not, Orlins’s colorful prose made me smile. A few of my favorites: “My idea was that a psychiatrist ought to be able to mold my mind, the way a plastic surgeon could change a person’s nose” (p. 62); “ ‘When we’re engaged, you can pick me up.’ If you have never gone through a divorce, let me propose you prepare for this kind of gut-flip-flopping, bile-choking, brain-exploding remark to just fall out of your mouth without warning. Peter was decent enough not to break the date” (p. 169); and “Don’t mistake me for a sleek, zippy cyclist hunched over racing-style handlebars. I am none of that. I plod along high and upright, arms spread wide, more Mary Poppins than Lance Armstrong” (p. 249).
Orlins’s delightful writing style, combined with a touching look back at the major relationships and events she’s lived through, made this a captivating read. I was sorry to reach the last chapter, and I highly recommend her book to any “worrywart” looking to peek into the mind of a kindred spirit.
]]>Confessions of a Worrywart: Husbands, Lovers, Mothers, and Others
Seneca Books, January, 2013
Paperback, 304 pages
$12.95
My son Dan suffered from obsessive-compulsive disorder so severe he could not even eat, and his anxiety levels were often so high, he could barely function. It would have been ludicrous for me to suggest he try yoga, or meditation, or any other stress reduction technique to help him feel better when, in fact, he could hardly get off the couch.
But he could pet our cats.
Our beautiful cats, Smokey and Ricky, both so lovable with distinct personalities, helped Dan immensely during those dark days. Whether they sat on his lap, curled up near him on the couch, or let him hold them, they allowed him to relax and brought him momentary peace. Sometimes they purred so loudly they sounded like engines revving, and this soothed Dan. Other times they would engage in various cat-like antics, inciting a rare, but oh-so-cherished laugh from our son.
They didn’t bombard him with questions, asking if he was okay, or if he was hungry, or what was wrong. They were just there with Dan, and for a short time, his focus was diverted from his obsessions and compulsions. Our pets were able to care for Dan in a way the rest of our family could not.
An article in the April 15, 2013 issue of Time magazine explored how animals grieve. I found it fascinating, and no matter how you might interpret the various studies discussed in the article, I think it is hard to argue with the belief that animals do indeed form relationships, and are empathetic. What more does it take to comfort someone?
For those obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) sufferers who struggle with germs and contamination issues, caring for a pet can elicit many triggers. Cleaning a litter box, letting a dog lick your face, or having to tend to a sick pet are just a few examples of what OCD sufferers might have to deal with. Surprisingly, I have heard from many with OCD who are amazed themselves that these situations do not cause their OCD to spring into action. Could it be that their love for their pets transcends the fear and anxiety of OCD?
When my son moved into his own apartment last year, one of the first things he did was foster a cat from a shelter. He has always been an animal lover, and was looking for a furry friend to keep him company. As he knows, life is full of surprises, and come to find out, his new companion has a host of medical problems and needs to take medication to control her seizures.
Instead of returning the cat to the animal shelter (something I very well might have done), he has embraced his role as her caretaker. Whether we have OCD or not, I believe this experience of putting another’s needs ahead of our own is worthwhile. Focusing outward instead of inward gives us a different perspective on our own lives and challenges.
So it works both ways. We take care of our beloved pets, and they take care of us. Whether our furry friend is a specially trained service dog who can sense an imminent anxiety attack (yes, it’s possible!) or an adored rabbit, pets can benefit us all in countless ways. They require us to slow down our lives, they make us laugh, and they give us unconditional love. And for those who are suffering, they provide the much-needed comfort and serenity that often can’t be found elsewhere.
]]>Jung’s work includes such relatively well-known ideas as the self, the collective unconscious, mandalas, psychological types, and archetypes. His formulation of each, along with other lesser-known elements of his teachings, is mapped out in Jung the Mystic against the life of a man who experienced a continual struggle between his tangible world and his spiritual one.
Jung himself was apparently much at odds with the characterization of his work as mysticism. However, as Lachman digs deeper into Jung’s growth to adulthood, we see his position becoming somewhat more complex regarding this controversy. Jung “seemed to have two minds about the supernatural: a public one that wanted to understand it ‘scientifically,’ and a private one that acknowledged ghosts, visions, and premonitions as part of the essential mystery of life.”
Lachman attempts to clarify this dualistic view of Jung’s thoughts and beliefs. His book is not for those who know little about psychology or psychoanalytic psychology, or about Jung’s approach. It is a better read for those who have already absorbed at least a basic understanding of Jungian concepts.
Lachman’s book is a fascinating treatment in considerable depth around the life and times of one of the great thinkers from the early years of psychology. From a developmental point of view, the book provides a fascinating series of vignettes that paint a vivid portrait of a man whose intellect still resonates today—along with a cogent and instructive review of his major concepts and terms. Lachman uses a biographical approach to match the life events of Jung with the formulation and confirmation of his major concepts, which together comprise Jung’s approach. This way of structuring the book is somewhat challenging, and for two good reasons:
The first section, aptly named “Memories, Dreams, Refractions,” is a rather clever play on the title of Jung’s own attempt at an autobiography, which was titled Memories, Dreams, Reflections. In that work, Jung talks of his life, although not of the major figures or sweeping world events that he experienced. Jung devotes more time to “ephemeral apparitions,” which he found to be at the center of his life experiences. A childhood spent primarily alone produced an odd combination of inner direction and a lifelong fascination with the more tangible enjoyments, such as mountains, water, and beer.
Lachman discusses Jung’s loneliness as a child and his creation of a “homunculus,” or little man, which he kept in a secret place and used as a repository for his fears and as an object of security in his insecure world. When he was older, this came back to Jung as a realization of his early involvement in a very common human tradition: that of creating a symbol. Jung would later use this as evidence of his ideas about our sharing a “collective unconscious,” things that humans share over the ages, often without conscious recognition of that sharing.
Early chapters include vignettes around Jung’s relationship with his father, whose life Jung felt “ended when he graduated” and who died relatively young. Upon his father’s death, Jung’s role in the family and in society changed. He became a more exuberant and outgoing person, which persona he would maintain throughout his life. Jung’s mother, Emilie, had a family history of spirituality and was even reported to have spoken with the dead. Her interest in and apparent affinity for the supernatural flowed to Jung and formed the basis of the controversy that would color his personal and professional life.
Other relationships and events continued to influence Jung, and each chapter reveals additional layers of Jung’s life in detail. Jung engaged in long-term relationships that informed both his personal and professional lives, including with Emma Jung, his wife; Toni Wolfe, a professional colleague and open mistress; and Ruth Bailey. We can see how Jung’s personal behavior and reflections on the stress between his “proper” upbringing and the realities of his family and work life provided much grist for his thoughts on a person’s continuing quest to become him- or herself.
Of particular note is Jung’s long relationship with Sigmund Freud. They were contemporaries, collaborators on occasion, and ultimately in conflict as Jung’s fascination with the supernatural led him further away from Freud’s focus on the scientific. Both thinkers dealt with human behavior and motivation that could only be observed and theorized about, often analyzing the same things but coming to different conclusions.
A running theme throughout the book is the image of the “Herr Doctor Professor,” which represents Jung’s own internal identity and also the major conflict between his desire to keep his work strictly scientific and his attraction to the decidedly non-scientific world of the supernatural. Chapter 6, “The Jung Cult,” is particularly useful in beginning the discussion about Jung’s break with Freud and his realization of some concepts that we often refer to today. As Lachman writes, “Jung’s ideas on the introvert, extravert, and the four functions—thinking, feelings, sensation, intuition—have become part of common parlance.” Anyone who is familiar with personality theory and behavioral assessment will feel very comfortable with these terms.
Lachman provides us with a detailed and sometimes overwhelming amount of information about Jung the man and Jung the mystic. If you desire to immerse yourself in the life and times of one of psychology’s great thinkers, his book will provide that opportunity. But, while Lachman provides much in the way of fascinating details and engaging stories, these attractive elements are often combined with somewhat challenging technical discussions of various Jungian theories.
]]>Jung the Mystic: The Esoteric Dimensions of Carl Jung’s Life and Teachings
Jeremy P. Tarcher/Penguin, June, 2010
Hardcover, 272 pages
$24.95
“Anxiety is a normal, predictable part of life,” said Tom Corboy, MFT, the founder and executive director of the OCD Center of Los Angeles, and co-author of the upcoming book The Mindfulness Workbook for OCD.
However, “people with an anxiety disorder are essentially phobic about the feeling state of anxiety.” And they’ll go to great lengths to avoid it.
Some people experience generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), excessive anxiety about real-life concerns, such as money, relationships, health and academics, he said.
Others struggle with society anxiety, and worry about being evaluated or embarrassing themselves, he said. People with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) might become preoccupied with symmetry or potential contamination, he said.
“The bottom line is that people can experience anxiety, and anxiety disorders, related to just about anything.”
Some people may not struggle with a clinical disorder, but want to manage sporadic (yet intrusive) bouts of anxiety and stress.
Whether you have occasional anxiety or a diagnosable disorder, the good news is that you can take small, effective and straightforward steps every day to manage and minimize your anxiety.
Most of these steps contribute to a healthy and fulfilling life, overall. For instance, “making some basic lifestyle changes can do wonders for someone coping with elevated anxiety,” Corboy said. Below, you’ll find 15 small steps you can take today.
1. Take a deep breath.
“Deep diaphragmatic breathing triggers our relaxation response, switching from our fight-or-flight response of the sympathetic nervous system, to the relaxed, balanced response of our parasympathetic nervous system,” according to Marla Deibler, PsyD, a clinical psychologist, executive director of The Center for Emotional Health of Greater Philadelphia and Psych Central blogger.
She suggested the following exercise, which you can repeat several times: Inhale slowly to a count of four, starting at your belly and then moving into your chest. Gently hold your breath for four counts. Then slowly exhale to four counts.
2. Get active.
“One of the most important things one can do [to cope with anxiety] is to get regular cardiovascular exercise,” Corboy said. For instance, a brisk 30- to 60-minute walk “releases endorphins that lead to a reduction in anxiety.”
You can start today by taking a walk. Or create a list of physical activities that you enjoy, and put them on your schedule for the week. Other options include: running, rowing, rollerblading, hiking, biking, dancing, swimming, surfing, step aerobics, kickboxing and sports such as soccer, tennis and basketball.
3. Sleep well.
Not getting enough sleep can trigger anxiety. If you’re having trouble sleeping, tonight, engage in a relaxing activity before bedtime, such as taking a warm bath, listening to soothing music or taking several deep breaths. (You’ll find more tips here.)
And, if you’re like many people with anxiety whose brains start buzzing right before bed, jot down your worries earlier in the day for 10 to 15 minutes, or try a mental exercise like thinking of fruits with the same letter. (Find more suggestions here.)
4. Challenge an anxious thought.
“We all have moments wherein we unintentionally increase or maintain our own worry by thinking unhelpful thoughts. These thoughts are often unrealistic, inaccurate, or, to some extent, unreasonable,” Deibler said.
Thankfully, we can change these thoughts. The first step is to identify them. Consider how a specific thought affects your feelings and behaviors, Deibler said. Is it helpful or unhelpful?
Unhelpful thoughts usually come in the form of “what ifs,” “all-or-nothing thinking,” or “catastrophizing,” Deibler said. She gave these examples: “What if I make a fool of myself?” “What if I fail this exam?” or “What if this airplane crashes?”
These are the types of thoughts you want to challenge. Deibler suggested asking yourself:
“Is this worry realistic?” “Is this really likely to happen?” “If the worst possible outcome happens, what would be so bad about that?” “Could I handle that?” “What might I do?” “If something bad happens, what might that mean about me?” “Is this really true or does it just seem that way?” “What might I do to prepare for whatever may happen?”
Then, “reframe or correct that thought to make it more accurate, realistic and more adaptive.” Here’s one example: “I would feel embarrassed if I tripped on the stage, but that’s just a feeling; it wouldn’t last forever, and I would get through it.”
5. Say an encouraging statement.
Positive, accurate statements can help to put things into perspective. Deibler gave these examples: “Anxiety is just a feeling, like any other feeling.” and “This feels bad, but I can use some strategies to [cope with] it.”
6. Stay connected to others.
“Social support is vital to managing stress,” Deibler said. Today, call a loved one, schedule a Skype date or go to lunch with a close friend. “Talking with others can do a world of good.” Another option is to get together and engage in an activity that improves your anxiety, such as taking a walk, sitting on the beach or going to a yoga class.
7. Avoid caffeine.
Managing anxiety is as much about what you do as what you don’t do. And there are some substances that exacerbate anxiety. Caffeine is one of those substances. As Corboy said, “The last thing people with anxiety need is a substance that makes them feel more amped up, which is exactly what caffeine does.”
8. Avoid mind-altering substances.
“While drugs and alcohol might help to reduce anxiety in the short term, they often do just the opposite in the long term,” Corboy said. Even the short-term effect can be harmful.
Corboy and his team have treated countless clients whose first panic attack occurred while they were taking drugs such as marijuana, ecstasy or LSD. “Panic attacks are bad enough if you are straight and sober, so imagine how bad they are if you are high, and can’t get un-high until the drug wears off.”
9. Do something you enjoy.
Engaging in enjoyable activities helps to soothe your anxiety. For instance, today, you might take a walk, listen to music or read a book, Deibler said.
10. Take a break.
It’s also helpful to build breaks into your day. As Deibler said, this might be a “simple change of pace or scenery, enjoying a hobby, or switching ‘to-do’ tasks.” “Breaking from concerted effort can be refreshing.”
11. Problem-solve.
Deibler suggested considering how you can address the stressors that are causing your anxiety. Today, make a list of these stressors and next to each one, jot down one or two solutions.
12. Pick up a book.
There are many valuable resources on anxiety, which teach you effective coping skills. Corboy recommended Dying of Embarrassment for people with social anxiety; The BDD Workbook for body dysmorphic disorder; The Imp of the Mind and The OCD Workbook for obsessive-compulsive disorder. Deibler suggested Stop Obsessing for adults with OCD (and Up and Down the Worry Hill for kids with OCD).
For people with panic attacks, she suggested Don’t Panic: Taking Control of Anxiety Attacks. For a general overview of cognitive-behavioral therapy for anxiety, Corboy recommended The Anxiety and Phobia Workbook. He also recommended Get Out of Your Mind and Into Your Life and The Wisdom of No Escape.
(You can find more book recommendations at Corboy’s website.)
13. Engage in calming practices.
According to Corboy, “meditation, yoga, or other calming practices can help minimize anxiety in both the short and long term.” Sign up for a yoga class or watch a yoga video online. (Curvy Yoga is a wonderful resource for yoga for all shapes and sizes.) Meditate right now for just three minutes. (Here’s how.)
14. Contact a therapist.
“Sometimes anxiety can be difficult to manage without professional help,” Deibler said. Many organizations include databases of providers who specialize in anxiety (along with helpful information). She suggested these organizations: www.ocfoundation.org, www.adaa.org and www.abct.org.
15. Accept your anxiety.
“If you really want to effectively manage your anxiety, the key is to accept it,” Corboy said. This might sound counterintuitive. But anxiety, “in and of itself,” isn’t the real problem. Instead, it’s our attempts at controlling and eliminating it, he said. “Not accepting these unwanted inner experiences is the actual source of so much of our self-induced suffering.”
Accepting anxiety doesn’t mean “resign[ing] ourselves to a life of anxious misery. It simply means that we are better off recognizing and fully accepting the existence of anxiety and other uncomfortable emotional states that are inevitable, but transitory,” Corboy said.
So if you experience anxiety today, simply observe it, Deibler said. “Think of it like a wave of the ocean; allow it to come in, experience it, and ride it out.”
Anxiety can feel overwhelming. It can feel like chains around your feet, weighing you down. But by taking small steps – like the ones above – you can minimize your anxiety and cope effectively.
]]>
In our monthly series, we give readers a behind-the-scenes glimpse into the professional and personal lives of psychotherapists. They share the triumphs, trials and surprises of seeing clients. They reveal what they’d like others to know about therapy (and life). And they share just how they personally cope with stress, among other tidbits.
This month we’re featuring Nathan Feiles, LMSW, a social worker and candidate in relational psychoanalytic and contemporary psychotherapy in the New York City area. Feiles is a regular contributor at Psych Central and pens the popular blog “Relationships in Balance.”
In his private practice, Feiles specializes in relationships — including couples counseling — life adjustments and transitions; stress reduction and prevention; depression; migraines; anxiety and social anxiety; and phobias. He also is the founder of the NYC Migraine Support Group and runs a comprehensive program to overcome the fear of flying.
For more information about Nathan Feiles, visit his website at www.nyclifeandrelationshipcounseling.com.
1. What’s surprised you the most about being a therapist?
As I work with people, there inevitably comes a point with each person where I see something (if not several things) that I can relate to. Having ways to relate to clients is a necessary component of being a good therapist (otherwise you’re relying on the power of pure altruism), but it’s surprised me how this seems to naturally happen with each person.
When [I was] first starting out as a therapist, the assumption was that I’d probably relate most with people who have shared a similar primary issue to something I’ve also experienced.
But I’ve found it common to be in the room with people of all different backgrounds and histories, and at some point end up thinking, “I can certainly relate to you, here.”
While as a therapist my job involves setting my own life aside in order to focus on the person (or people) in front of me, I believe that this ability to empathize below the surface and in some way connect with each person is one of the reasons I love what I do. Within everyone there is something to connect with and appreciate.
2. What’s the latest and greatest book you’ve read related to mental health, psychology, or psychotherapy?
I recently read The Marriage Clinic by Dr. John Gottman. This book resonates with aspects of my relationship therapy approach – opening communication and generally removing the idealizations from the relationship picture, while focusing more towards creating and harnessing positive sentiment for a healthier and more fulfilling relationship.
3. What’s the biggest myth about therapy?
There are many myths to choose from, but the myth surrounding venting grabs my attention. I’ve heard people say that if they need to talk or vent, why should they go to a therapist? Can’t they just go to a friend? Two issues with this: 1) not everyone has a close friend to go to; and 2) while venting is fully welcome and can be part of therapy, therapy is for more than just venting.
Venting can be useful to temporarily relieve stress (and venting can actually increase stress, if not careful), but at some point, a person in therapy will have to look into themselves and their own cognitive and emotional processes. The process that makes therapy effective isn’t as likely to happen effectively with a friend (even if the friend is a therapist). Therapy isn’t only talk and conversation, nor is it advice-giving (another myth).
Therapy involves a dynamic relationship in its own right, which a personal history conflicts with. That’s why it is unethical for therapists to work with their friends. Therapy is most effective when entered pure – without personal history. Therefore, while it’s nice to be able to vent to friends, if you’re looking for an effective therapy experience, this is much more likely to happen with a therapist than when talking to a friend.
4. What seems to be the biggest obstacle for clients in therapy?
The obstacle that I see repeat most is the desire to change and move forward, versus the unconscious desire to stay “comfortable” – even if the “comfortable” is unhealthy or harmful. In every person, no matter how much they want to change, there’s a subconscious desire to work against change. The unknown of change can seem daunting, at times, and this is where people often become the most unconsciously resistant to their therapy.
For example: A person who is used to isolating finds they are establishing a meaningful therapeutic relationship with their therapist. This is anxiety-provoking because the person is used to arm’s-distance relationships. As the therapy is about to go deeper, the person decides to stop going to therapy. Thus, the person breaks the process of moving forward, because the fear of the unknown change is more scary than sticking with something less healthy, but something they’ve survived for so long: isolation.
5. What’s the most challenging part about being a therapist?
The endings. At some point, whether after six months or many years, people finish their treatment. There is an alliance, care, and bond that forms with each person. When treatment ends, it can be sad for the therapists, too. While this is a given part of the work, it’s never easy.
6. What do you love about being a therapist?
The people (clients). The ability to know so many people, and help people create fulfillment in their lives is an incredibly rewarding journey.
7. What’s the best advice you can offer to readers on leading a meaningful life?
Focus on what you can control. There are things in life we can’t control. These things usually cause stress and anxiety. It’s much more useful to focus on what is within our control.
8. If you had your schooling and career choice to do all over again, would you choose the same professional path? If not, what would you do differently, and why?
I’m very happy with what I do.
9. If there’s one thing you wished your clients or patients knew about treatment or mental illness, what would it be?
I wish people saw getting help as a sign of strength, rather than a weakness. People who attempt to do it all alone often end up struggling the most before they finally “give in” for help. Pride can make us think that there’s something advantageous to struggling through life without going to anyone for help. But in reality, there are no points awarded for struggling alone, nor is there shame in getting help with the challenges of life.
10. What personally do you do to cope with stress in your life?
As a therapist who partially specializes in stress reduction and prevention, I do my best to practice what I preach. Stress is a state of mind. Therefore, as mentioned above, I try to focus on what is within my control, rather than letting things outside of my control create unwanted stress.
While there are behavioral exercises that I can (and do) use in times of acute stress, I find that setting the environment for stress prevention is the most helpful. This involves such things as establishing boundaries between my work life and personal life, scheduling in some weekly form of self-care, and generally surrounding myself around people who make me feel good.
So I would say I cope with stress by preventing it as much as possible, and when I have a notable level of stress that I’m presented with, I have an internal list of cognitive and behavioral coping skills that I go to, which combine to physically relax me, as well as re-frame my mindset away from stress.
]]>
It is estimated that one in every four people are variously affected each year with some mental health concern. The National Institute of Mental Health has documented that only one-third of them get treatment. Whether these individuals seek out treatment or back into it under pressure, the number of people who believe that mental health is a component of overall health is even lower.
Treatment is warranted when mental illness strikes. It could be as simple as acknowledgement (vs. denial) and getting involved in exercise, support groups, hobbies, anything that noticeably lessens the burden and eases the mind. If the illness is debilitating, ongoing medication or short-term hospitalization might be needed. Study and application of effective behavioral strategies and therapy are middle-ground treatments that can bring needed understanding, relief and coping mechanisms for symptom flare-ups or deeper issues.
The people behind Mental Health First Aid (MHFA), a relatively new program in this country, hope to educate laypeople about mental health concerns. Their focus is relatively simple: training people how to spot acute mental health symptoms in friends, neighbors and colleagues and guide them to treatment. Mental health advocacy also is rolled up in this equation.
My work as vocational coordinator at a psychosocial rehab agency years ago involved finding meaningful work for folks with mental health diagnoses. But due to necessity I had to be an advocate, first, for mental illness. Whether minor depression or schizophrenia, if you are talking to employers, you quickly realize that mental illness needs to be destigmatized in order for any progress to be made.
MHFA’s goal of guiding people to treatment also involves identifying the difference between functional and temporarily nonfunctional states. If only this continuum of real distress could be better understood by a broad public, acute mental health care in this country could be vastly improved, advocacy could be championed, and people would begin to see that true health is more than just physical.
Mental Health First Aid had its beginnings in Australia in 2001. A professor, Tony Jorm, and nurse, Betty Kitchener, created it in affiliation with the University of Melbourne. Studies soon documented its effectiveness in saving lives and improving the mental health of the layperson giving the care and guidance. According to MHFA program material, “just as CPR training helps a layperson without medical training assist an individual following a heart attack, Mental Health First Aid training helps a layperson assist someone experiencing a mental health crisis.”
So successful was this Australian pilot program that other countries followed suit, including the U.S. in 2008, and communities are now offering the training course. Hospital, nursing home and school personnel initially took part. (One might think professionals in these arenas might not need the training, but mental illness often is out of the scope of those who deal with physical illness and trauma.) It’s envisioned that someday the training will be as common as that for cardiopulmonary rehabilitation (CPR).
Typically a 12-hour course over two days, it includes identification of risk factors and “warning signs of mental health problems.” An overview of treatment options is given, including individual information on depression, anxiety, psychosis, substance abuse, and even eating disorders and self-injury.
Integral to MHFA is a five-step action plan regarding skills needed for situation assessment, implementation of appropriate interventions, and connecting the person in distress to available resources on a spectrum of professional, peer, social and self-help. Part of the training reinforces nonjudgmental listening, as well as reassuringly imparting information about available resources in the gentlest, yet most effective manner.
An excellent video of a MHFA role-play can be found on the national website. Two individuals are seen acting out dialogue as if neighbors talking on a porch. The man raps on the door of a woman who he feels has not been doing well. He asks nonthreatening questions in a soothing, helpful manner, and asks her to come out on the porch to talk to him. His words seem comforting and he acknowledges that her feelings (which seem to be paranoiac) must be very scary. He suggests a call to the crisis team, to come and simply talk to her. He says, tellingly, “If I were this upset, wouldn’t you want to help me?” The role-play comes to a good conclusion and the actors reflect, for the camera audience, on what went well.
Mike Gruber is just one of many professionals teaching MHFA in Allegheny County, Penn. Quoting a Pittsburgh City Paper reporter in a recent article, Gruber feels that what is the experiential approach of MHFA makes it “more effective at reducing stigma than would a public-awareness campaign.”
The National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare is asking for the public to sign, on their website, letters of support for MHFA legislation. (Staffer Meena Dayak is available to answer related questions.) H.R. 274 would authorize $20 million for the program in 2014. One of three templates to congressional leaders mentions that MHFA was endorsed as a best practice for state and local governments, and this is indeed the direction that the National Council would like to gain momentum in, according to the organization, striving for training across as many local communities as possible in the U.S.
]]>To find MHFA near you, visit this website
Like all dog people, I know that dogs have every emotion that humans have. Like all dog people, I know that dogs are smart and can solve puzzles as well as a four- or five-year-old human. Like all dog people, I know my dog loved me.
Well, that’s what I “know.” But, what does science know? That’s the premise of Virginia Morell’s book, Animal Wise: The Thoughts and Emotions of Our Fellow Creatures. What do animals know? What do they think? How do they think? And how do we know?
Morell’s book is easy and fun to read. She’s sorted through a great deal of research and talked to scientists galore to make sense of ethology and animal cognition. She was successful: The book is a great and educational read. I imagine any animal lover will love the book. Additionally, I think any psychology or biology major should be required to read it.
Morell discusses the research of and her conversations and visits with the scientists studying ants, fish, parrots, rats, elephants, dolphins, primates, and dogs. I’d seen papers and blurbs on science blogs about the intelligence of birds. I think it was during this last decade that scientists demonstrated that crows make tools. Intelligent elephants aren’t surprising, since “a memory like an elephant” is in our vernacular. I watched “Flipper” as a kid, and I read a lot of science fiction, so I know dolphins are smart. Primates share more than 98% of our DNA, and dogs know the proper time to steal muffins off kitchen tables. None of those critters surprised me. But ants? Fish? Really?
Morell visited a scientist studying tiny little ants, the size of a period on the screen. The scientist and his students had to study the ants under microscopes, and whole colonies lived in Petri dishes. The first thing he and his students did with each colony was to paint three dots on each individual ant so they could tell the ants apart from each other. He showed Morell an experiment where he put another “house” in the Petri dish that met the basic ant requirements. Then he took the roof off their home.
A few ants looked for a new house and found the prepared one. Then, the ants taught other ants how to find the new abode. Once enough ants knew how to get to the new dwelling, they started picking up their comrades and carrying them to the new place. The teaching process showed that the ants did more with their neurons than previously thought—and these critters don’t even have spines.
Fish are at least vertebrates. Spitting fish was another scientist’s area of research. The fish could learn new ways to hit targets. They even seemed to play a game of spitting on the humans.
The research on the other animals Morell discusses wasn’t nearly as surprising, but it was equally amazing. Apparently, some primates have eidetic memories. That is, they see in pictures. Because of that, they can perform some memory tasks much better than humans can. This rubbed some people wrong, so they had people practice, and yes, with practice humans can get almost as good as the chimps.
Why do we think that we need to be better than other animals at every task? That was another one of Morell’s themes in the book. Each species has evolved to be good in its niche. We humans don’t need to outperform chimps on bizarre memory tests, just as we don’t need amazing accuracy when we spit. Why do we feel like we have to be the best? Why are some humans bothered by the idea that other species have theory of mind?
Speaking of feelings, Morell also talks about emotions and the question of whether or not animals feel like we do. One scientist pretty much proved that rats could laugh. Another study showed that rats will forgo a treat if it will save their friend some pain. A researcher demonstrated that young rats look forward to “play dates” and get excited when they get to play with their friends. Elephants remember the sounds made by deceased members of their clan, and they react upon hearing them. They also show more interest in elephant bones than in other bones, and they shore more interest in the bones of elephants they knew than they do in the bones of elephants they didn’t know.
Morell gives examples showing us what all animal lovers know: Animals think and animals have feelings.
The City of Boulder, in Colorado, rewrote their laws to change some wording. In Boulder, you don’t “own” animals. Instead, you are “guardian for” animals. Many people thought Boulder went a little over the top with that legislation, but after reading Morell’s book, I don’t think they did. Individuals who can laugh, play, make tools, remember events and others from decades past, and outperform others on memory tests shouldn’t be owned. We should cherish and love them, not possess them.
Are you doubtful that animals deserve guardianship? Read Morell’s book. I bet you’ll change your mind.
]]>Animal Wise: The Thoughts and Emotions of Our Fellow Creatures
Crown, February, 2013
Hardcover, 304 pages
$26
Therapy isn’t just tough for clients. It’s also tough for therapists, especially when they have to deliver difficult feedback to their clients. For instance, clinicians might need to challenge their clients’ denial or self-destructive habits. They might need to tell them things they don’t want to hear.
But while challenging, this is vital work. “I believe some of our most powerful work as therapists occurs through the ability to tolerate very uncomfortable or difficult news, moments or feelings and continue to stay present and empathically connected to the client,” said Joyce Marter, LCPC, a therapist and owner of the counseling practice Urban Balance.
Difficult feedback comes in many forms. For instance, Marter had to help a client realize that her husband, who admitted to an “emotional affair” with a colleague, was still hiding a big skeleton about the relationship. According to Marter:
I certainly didn’t know the truth of the matter, but as therapists, we can tell when stories don’t make sense and there is missing information. I asked several questions to try and get a more complete picture.
When my nagging suspicions remained, I said to her, “Have you considered the possibility that his story is not the full truth?”
She was quiet and visibly displeased and we sat in some discomfort for a few moments. I had to tolerate the discomfort and not sweep it all back under the rug again.
I felt worried that I pushed her too far, but she came back the next session and said she confronted her husband and learned he had been sleeping with that woman for many years. Our conversation was a difficult but necessary part of her growth and recovery, and she is doing fabulously without him!
Another time Marter had to tell a self-conscious client that his lack of luck with women stemmed from his grooming habits. Not wanting to hurt his feelings, Marter skirted around the issue for several weeks. But, ultimately, she decided to be straightforward. (He started a relationship three months after this session.)
This kind of candor helps clients become more self-aware and encourages growth. Plus, it fosters the relationship between client and therapist.
“Being honest and direct with clients is a very genuine, authentic, intimate experience. The initial discomfort of the tough feedback will pass, the client will see that you are invested in them and care enough to be real, and the therapeutic relationship will deepen,” Marter said.
Deborah Serani, Psy.D, a clinical psychologist and author of the book Living with Depression, had to deliver difficult feedback in the form of a diagnosis. She vividly remembers having to tell a young couple, who was in deep denial, that their son has autism.
There was a great deal of heartache at the moment of the diagnostic disclosure. Their grief, confusion and shock shifted them into a true crisis state. Though I felt great sadness delivering this news, I also felt hopeful and confident that early detection and early intervention would offer significant help for this little boy. It’s never easy for a psychologist to deliver a diagnosis – nor is it ever easy for a parent to receive it.
John Duffy, Ph.D, a clinical psychologist and author of the book The Available Parent: Radical Optimism for Raising Teens and Tweens, regularly shares difficult feedback with parents. Recently he talked with a couple about whether the high school they chose for their son was really in his best interest.
“They were both alums of this prestigious private school, but he was, for many reasons, clearly better suited for the local high school. They were not pleased with the feedback, to be honest, but they did understand.”
He also gives tough feedback to his teen clients. He described a recent example:
I told a boy that he could not blame his academic lapses on his parents’ recent separation. He so wanted to hold that as his excuse, and I knew he was hiding from the reality of his own accountability.
In fact, experience told me that were it not the separation, he would have blamed some other external facet of his life. So, I had to tell him his D’s and F’s were on him. That was the bad news.
The accompanying good news was that he had the power to do something about them as well. There is almost always some good news underlying the bad.
Duffy used to feel anxious about giving this kind of feedback. But he doesn’t anymore. “This is part of the job, and the reason that people entrust us with their well-being. Holding back will only protect you the therapist, not your client.”
Marter agreed. “As therapists, there are times we need to say the things that other people have not been able to say to our clients. Not saying anything is a form of colluding, enabling or even neglect.”
The inherent nature of therapy can spark difficult discussions. “It’s always difficult to let clients know that the issues they want to overcome may take some time,” said Ryan Howes, Ph.D, a clinical psychologist and author of the blog “In Therapy.” Their concerns “will take months or more to understand, treat, and (hopefully) resolve.”
But time isn’t the only tough topic. When clients start to delve into their stories, they often realize that instead of one issue, they have three. Around the fourth or fifth session, Howes said, clients start to feel overwhelmed and wonder why they’re coming to therapy in the first place.
Consequently, he helps his clients understand that it’ll “get worse before it gets better.”
I try to reassure them that this is a common experience and that they’re not facing this alone; we’re working to understand and resolve the issues together. As we develop a treatment plan and begin to see tangible progress, the overwhelmed feelings change into a sense of control and hope.
When working with clients who have depression, Jeffrey Sumber, M.A., a psychotherapist, author and teacher, often tackles a difficult theme: Depression may serve his clients in some way. He frankly asks: “How is your depression serving you?”
While many people have depression because of biological and genetic vulnerabilities, Sumber finds that “many others find a home in depression as a reaction to pain, disappointment, fear, anxiety, etc.”
Sumber can relate to feeling “right at home in the warm womb of deep sadness.” He struggled with depression in his early 20s. After much inner work, he realized that “depression was in essence a defense mechanism that I used readily.”
According to Sumber:
When working with these folks, it can be a very difficult moment in treatment when I must confront the component of melancholy that is voluntary; however, I find that relying on my own history and path to recovery has been instrumental in supporting people in trusting that I am not discounting their experience but rather, expanding it.
Delivering difficult feedback can be a challenge for therapists. And it’s certainly rough on clients, too. But, ultimately, these kinds of discussions encourage positive growth and change.
Do you have to communicate a difficult message or news to someone else? Marter shared several tips for doing so constructively. First, she recommended reflecting on this quote from Shirdi Sai Baba: “Before you speak, ask yourself: Is it kind, is it necessary, it is true, does it improve upon the silence?”
If the answer is “yes,” then speak “simply, honestly and directly, with compassion and respect.”
She also suggested delivering hard news in person (not text or email) and giving the person your undivided attention (no technology use). “Choose a time and space that is quiet and confidential and free of interruptions.”
Separate your own response from the other person’s, she said. “You may each have different feelings about the news and that is OK. Allow the person to have their own response, and demonstrate empathy.”
]]>
“Depression is like many other common medical conditions, such as high blood pressure or diabetes,” said William R. Marchand, M.D., a clinical associate professor of psychiatry at the University of Utah School of Medicine and author of the book Depression and Bipolar Disorder: Your Guide to Recovery. It’s highly treatable, and effective interventions are available. But there’s a risk that symptoms will return.
According to Dr. Marchand, the risk of recurrence — “relapse after full remission” — for a person who’s had one episode of depression is 50 percent. For a person with two episodes, the risk is about 70 percent. For someone with three episodes or more, the risk rises to around 90 percent.
That’s why having a prevention plan is critical, he said. “Depression is often a chronic illness, but with a good prevention plan in place, it is often possible to prevent recurrences entirely or limit the severity and duration if depression does return.”
A prevention plan must include maintenance treatment, which is “treatment that is continued after symptoms are in remission to prevent recurrence.” This includes medication, psychotherapy or both, Marchand said. (If you’re currently receiving or have received treatment, make sure you have a prevention plan.)
It’s also important to understand what might trigger a possible relapse, and how you can prevent or minimize the influence of those triggers. Below, you’ll find three common triggers for depression, along with information on navigating a relapse.
“The biggest issue regarding relapse has to do with children and adults not following through on their treatment plan,” said Deborah Serani, Psy.D, a clinical psychologist and author of the book Living with Depression. This includes anything from skipping therapy sessions to missing doses of your medication to ending therapy too soon, she said.
If you don’t want to take your medication because of side effects (or other reasons), talk to your prescribing physician about these issues. They may reduce your dose, prescribe a different medication or recommend another strategy to minimize side effects and respond to your concerns. Similarly, if you’re dissatisfied with your therapy sessions (or you’re having a hard time getting to your appointments because of logistics), speak up.
Depression, like other chronic illnesses, requires “commitment and management. [Y]ou have to learn to live with it every day but not allow it to define you,” Serani said. How? Focus on celebrating your strengths. “While your life may involve psychotherapy, medication and the need for a protective structure that keeps your illness at bay, also realize that you have passions, desires, gifts and talents that require just as much attention.”
Also, “make sure you take extra special care of your mind, body and soul,” Serani said. “This means being attentive to your sleep cycle, moving your body with exercise [and] eating wisely and well.”
“Negative self-referential ruminations play…a key role in recurrence,” Marchand said. For example, individuals with depression tend to dwell on their (supposed) flaws and failures. They also may view neutral events with a negative lens.
That’s why it’s important to develop a strategy for managing these thinking patterns, he said. “Cognitive therapy or mindfulness-based interventions are particularly useful in this regard.”
“Triggers may be very specific to each individual’s situation, since all of our emotional responses are unique to some extent,” Marchand said. To identify your triggers, “learn how to recognize the who, what, whys and whens of your emotional and physical life,” Serani said.
Look at your calendar for potentially difficult periods. For instance, this might be an anniversary of a divorce or death or anxiety about a mammogram, Serani said. Highlighting these days “allows you to anticipate and plan for threats to depression recovery.”
Also important is to “take an inventory of all the hats you wear in your life.” Serani suggested considering these questions: “What circumstances at work affect your mood and behavior? At home, do certain actions of those around you tend to upset you? Are you feeling supported or overwhelmed? What happens when you don’t get enough ‘me’ time?”
Check in with your physical state, Serani said. “If you find yourself excessively fatigued, irritable, having trouble eating or sleeping, you might be in the midst of a trigger event.”
Finally, you can identify triggers by “think[ing] about previous depressive episodes and determin[ing] if there were specific triggers,” Marchand said.
Sometimes it’s not possible to prevent a relapse. But by knowing the early signs and getting treatment right away, you can prevent a full-blown episode or lessen its severity and length.
“Generally, early relapse will take hold with subtle signs, like mild irritability and sadness,” Serani said. Tracking your mood states every day helps you spot these early, not-so-obvious signs. “Through journaling, mindful reflection, and even apps on the computer, keeping a running tab on mood states can help offset relapse.” For example, if you’ve logged in 7 to 10 days of negative measurements, contact your practitioner to get evaluated for a relapse, she said.
Marchand also stressed the importance of contacting your doctor or therapist “at the first evidence of recurrence. Interventions may include restarting medication or psychotherapy… [I]f [you’re] in maintenance treatment [it’ll include]…adjusting [the] frequency of therapy or the medication dose.”
If you have a relapse, you might feel overwhelmed, frustrated and deeply disappointed. But “don’t measure your success living with depression on whether relapse happens or not. Instead, realize that if relapse occurs, true success comes from rising after the fall,” said Serani, who’s had depression herself. Her mantra is the Japanese proverb: “Fall down seven times, get up eight.”
And, again, whether you have a relapse or not, take good care of yourself, seek support and show yourself some compassion. Depression is a difficult illness. But, with treatment and healthy strategies, you can manage (and possibly eliminate) your symptoms and get better.
]]>