Psych Central


Do You Argue Like Romney & Obama?This guest article from YourTango was written by Dr. Bonnie Ray Kennan.

I would love to be a fly on the wall when Democratic strategist James Carville and his Republican commentator wife, Mary Matalin end their day. No, I am not talking about their sex life. I’m curious about their fighting style.

They must have figured out how to “fight” in a very different way at home than they do at work. Otherwise, contempt would most likely have already destroyed their marriage.

Red state-blue state battles are ubiquitous these days. Try turning on your television, radio or any i-device. Go to church, synagogue, Starbucks or the movies. Venture out to the office, a family dinner or read your Facebook page. Just notice how long it takes to find someone who is willing to tell you, with absolute certainty, why their presidential candidate is the true and living candidate who will provide all the answers for a broken country.

The fighting style of our culture at large is so mean-spirited and nasty. Equally appalling is that we reward our political candidates for their participation in the bloodier aspects of the game. Negative campaigning works.

Political candidates are essentially saying to the American people: Have a relationship with me and I will make your life better. I think we can tell a lot about them by the way they fight and by watching them, we can learn how not to fight as well as how to fight more effectively.

3 Tips to For Better Arguing

Maybe it is too late to have a civilized political exchange, but perhaps we can extract some communication lessons from the macro level for people to use on a micro level. Here’s how:

1. Avoid sarcasm while arguing. 

Check out YourTango for relationship advice

Notice what you feel toward a candidate or his/her surrogate when they make a sarcastic remark. That is a big deal-killer. Sarcasm is a bad communication strategy in any arena. It is indirect, smug, one-up and mean. It is far more effective to say it clear, clean and directly.

2. Be straight forward with your perspective. 

How do you feel when a candidate catastrophizes? Or in other words uses wild hyperbole to make a point about “what will happen if … ” This is a very immoderate and hysterical way to communicate. Instead, why not lay out a clean, straight-forward case for your perspective, then make an earnest request for what you want.

3. Don’t over-exaggerate your point. 

How do you feel when a candidate’s presentation is so grandiose and overstated and filled with downright lies? This tactic destroys trust and credibility, even if it gets attention.

I suspect politics is what it is and not likely to change. If anything, it is getting worse. However, this hot political season can serve as a “How Not To Communicate” guide for the vast majority of us who are not running for anything. In short, keep it clean, direct and respectful.

And when you lose your way and go below the belt, remember it says much more about you than it says about your spouse. Then, make every attempt to repair the damage and reconnect with your partner.

 

More relationship advice from YourTango:

 


Comments


View Comments / Leave a Comment

This post currently has 0 comments.
You can read the comments or leave your own thoughts.

Trackbacks


    Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 5 Nov 2012
    Published on PsychCentral.com. All rights reserved.

APA Reference
Experts, Y. (2012). Do You Argue Like Romney & Obama?. Psych Central. Retrieved on April 18, 2014, from http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2012/11/05/do-you-argue-like-romney-obama/

 

Recent Comments
  • Elizabeth: This is one of my favorite of your recent posts. I am the same as you were when you said: “Like most...
  • Elizabeth: I read this post a few weeks ago and found it really interesting and I want to read her book. My father is...
  • Hello: When you say people can rise above this using other means…what are these other ways? IMHO bullying works...
  • Maureen: Hi I dont know if” i am in a abusive relationhship even though i know i should as i was in one before...
  • Fritters: I have the same “what now” question.
Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter


Find a Therapist
Enter ZIP or postal code



Users Online: 12085
Join Us Now!