Rotenberg Center: Is This Torture or Treatment for Teen?After a decade old legal battle, the Judge Rotenberg Center lost its effort to bar the public from viewing how “treatment” is administered at the facility. In this troubling, emotional video, we see then 18-year-old Andre McCollins repeatedly shocked 31 times. His crime? Failure to remove his jacket in a timely manner.

His family has brought a lawsuit against the Center, saying they never expected their teen to be tortured as a form of “treatment.” The Judge Rotenberg Center 8 years ago convinced a judge not to let the public see the video. But during a hearing today, Superior Court Judge Barbara Dortch-Okara refused to bar the local Fox television station from videotaping the recording.

Which means — for the first time ever — the public gets to see the “treatment” used by the Judge Rotenberg Center. I use that term loosely, because in almost any other setting or environment, most ordinary people would call this torture.

Click through to watch the video. But be warned — it is disturbing.

The strange defense offered by Rotenberg Center clinicians is that the “treatment plan was followed.” That is an eerily familiar refrain we heard in the past, when war criminals are brought before courts to answer for crimes against humanity — “I was only following orders.”

McCollins, then 18-years-old, was shocked 31 times that day in 2002. Lawyers for the center and its clinicians say it was part of the treatment he needed to quell his aggressive behavior.

“These are dramatic tapes, there’s no question about that,” said attorney Edward Hinchey, who represents two of the Rotenberg Center’s clinicians. “But the treatment plan at the Rotenberg Center, the treatment plan that Andre had in place on October 25, was followed.”

In other words, even if this is incredibly disturbing and seemingly wrong, it’s okay, because it’s just a part of the teen’s “treatment plan.” I suppose if the treatment plan had also included things like “no food for 3 days at a time” or “waterboarding,” we’d be hearing similar arguments.

Click on the video below to watch:

While I have no doubt that the Judge Rotenberg Center is a well-meaning treatment center for troubled youth staffed by professionals, its methods are better suited for a different era… like the Middle Ages.

Read the full story: Video of teen restrained, shocked for hours expected to be played in court


    Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 10 Apr 2012
    Published on All rights reserved.

APA Reference
Grohol, J. (2012). Rotenberg Center: Is This Torture or Treatment for Teen?. Psych Central. Retrieved on January 26, 2015, from


Recent Comments
  • dave: absoloute rubbish so outdated,my addictive behaviour ran deep for thirty five years and used to class myself as...
  • Thea: Not only are conditions dramatically different from place to place (fresh air? wifi? bowling? really?), but...
  • Kathryn: I enjoyed your article so much. I was in the midst of a panic attack when I found the article and it helped...
  • fish65: I guess this site is for men to. I have been married for 45 years my wife is very I’ll and confined to...
  • Nada: Thank you Therese for your terrific piece on the urge to “sneeze”! I’ve had the urge a few...
Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

Find a Therapist
Enter ZIP or postal code

Users Online: 6074
Join Us Now!