Psych Central


myths about memoryMemory is important in everyday judgments and decision-making.  In some way or another, memory affects most aspects of our lives.  It is no surprise that there are many myths about memory.

Memory involves processing of information in different stages: sensory, short-term, and long-term.  However, the mechanics of memory are not my concern in this article.

Here, I’ll focus on a couple of popular myths about memory.  Donald Varakin, cognitive scientist, sheds light on these myths. So I posed the following question to Dr. Varakin…

I am aware there are numerous myths about memory.  What have you found to be the two most common myths? It’s probably hard to limit it to two, but assuming you can only give us two, what would they be?

Here’s Dr. Varakin’s reply:

1. Some people have photographic memory. This means a memory that is as detailed as perception.  There is no evidence that photographic memory exists… in anyone.  A photographic memory would be non-selective, i.e. it would encode everything from a given picture.  However, evidence suggests that memory is selective.

Information that is attentively processed tends to be encoded, and information that is not attentively processed tends not to be encoded.  What’s more, two bits of information encoded from a given picture aren’t necessarily integrated in memory (Varakin & Loschky, 2010, QJEP).  In other words, the information that is encoded from pictures is not stored and/or retrieved in the same manner as photographs.

The best evidence for photographic memory is at best highly suspect and not to be trusted.  It comes from a paper published in the journal Nature in the 1970’s (Stromeyer, C. F., Psotka, J. (1970). The detailed texture of eidetic images. Nature 225 (5230): 346–349).  The problems with this report are numerous: only one subject was tested, the subject happened to be the investigator’s wife, the wife has refused testing by other researchers, and no other researchers have been able to replicate the results.  Of course, to say that no one has a photographic memory is not to deny that some people have extraordinary memory skills.  But even people with extraordinary memory skills don’t encode everything they perceive.

2. Confident recollections are accurate recollections. Our memories can be distorted by a host of factors, most notably post-event information.  Elizabeth Loftus’s work in this area is probably the most well known.  In her research, she has demonstrated time and time again that memory for a given event is affected by experiences that happen after the event, leading to false memories.  There is a relationship between confidence and accuracy of recollection, but the relationship is not very strong.  In other words, high-confidence memories can be totally inaccurate.

About Donald Varakin

Varakin received his Ph.D. in psychological science from Vanderbilt University, and is now on the faculty at Eastern Kentucky University.  His current research focuses on how external (e.g. perceptual organization) and internal (e.g. task-related goals) factors affect how visual information is perceived and remembered.

Photo by Steve Jurvetson, available under a Creative Commons attribution license.

 


Comments


View Comments / Leave a Comment

This post currently has 0 comments.
You can read the comments or leave your own thoughts.

Trackbacks


    Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 19 May 2011
    Published on PsychCentral.com. All rights reserved.

APA Reference
Hale, J. (2011). Myths about Memory. Psych Central. Retrieved on April 24, 2014, from http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2011/05/19/myths-about-memory/

 

Recent Comments
  • leanna: I thought your honesty was wonderful. However I would like to point something out. When you said it is hard...
  • L William Yolton: Nancy Jensen had a moment to testify, and then had no follow up. She was isolated as the only voice...
  • BusyBee: I must have ADHD. Half of these suggestions I have done. It has helped alot. Thanks!
  • June Judge: We need this discussion. Why are we blind to those who become homeless or incarcerated..due to untreated...
  • Annie: My son was diognosed as having aspergis syndrome but we are now waiting to see the pediatrition again as...
Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter


Find a Therapist
Enter ZIP or postal code



Users Online: 7232
Join Us Now!