I chalk this up to the category, “This is news how, exactly?”
Here’s the finding in a nutshell — “After arrival in the United States, [Mexican] migrants had a significantly higher risk for first onset of any depressive or anxiety disorder than did non-migrant family members of migrants in Mexico,” the authors report.
Wow, surprising. You mean going to a foreign country, not necessarily knowing anyone, not necessarily having any job or job prospects, and not necessarily knowing the language can negatively impact your mental health?
The researchers “compared a sample of Mexican-born migrants (259 men and 295 women) after their arrival in the U.S. with a sample of non-migrants in Mexico (904 men and 1,615 women) on their risk for first onset of a depressive or anxiety disorder.” They surveyed people in both countries, apparently face-to-face, to gather their data.
The news release didn’t say how great the increased risk was, just that the migrants who moved to the U.S. had a “significantly higher risk.”
I imagine the same could be set for virtually any ethnic group tracked in a foreign country.
This isn’t particularly helpful, because we already know that many ethnic groups are at greater risk for not seeking help for depression. For instance, previous research has shown that Latinos’ culture hampers depression treatment and that different ethnic groups respond differently to antidepressants. I don’t know of any recent research specifically that has looked at Mexican treatment rates for mental health concerns, but I suspect they are closer to Latino rates than Caucasian rates of treatment.
Moving is a stressful life event. We already know that. In fact, it’s one of the largest stressful life events you can encounter, especially when it involves a geographic move — even within your own country.
Is it really that surprising — or of much “news” — to show that when people from one culture move to another country of a different culture entirely, that their mental health is going to suffer, at least temporarily?
I’d argue, not really. We already knew this, and the real challenge remains — how to help people who already don’t always fit into their new society, to reach out to them, who don’t understand or necessarily believe in mental health concerns, and help them get help if they are in need.
Sadly, this new research doesn’t provide us any new insights into those issues.
This post currently has
You can read the comments or leave your own thoughts.
Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 5 Apr 2011
Published on PsychCentral.com. All rights reserved.
Grohol, J. (2011). Coming to America Can Increase Depression, Anxiety?. Psych Central. Retrieved on December 11, 2013, from http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2011/04/05/coming-to-america-can-increase-depression-anxiety/