Email Not That Effective with College DepressionI’m always on the lookout for how technology can better help people with mental health issues. But some uses of technology leave me scratching my head. Take, for instance, this one:

If you email a depression assessment quiz to college students, some will take it. Some of those who take it will have depression.

Those are the astounding findings from a research study presented the other day at the annual meeting of the American Psychiatric Association.

But few of the students who received the email at four different colleges bothered taking the quiz — only 691 students — suggesting that it remains an ineffective way of reaching students (except those who may already believe they have or may be at risk for depression).

Worse yet, the email quiz did nothing to encourage students to seek out treatment for depression…

But few students who screened positive for depression with the Patient Health Questionnaire 9-Item (PHQ-9) actually used the online educational resources or on-campus peer health support groups provided in the e-mail. [...]

[Researchers] said that only seven of them used the online health information resource links, and just one attended on-campus counseling groups [out of 82 students identified with depression].

So the take away seems to be that some students will take a depression quiz emailed to them. But even after being given a followup email about depression treatment resources available to them on their campus, few students make use of such resources. What started out as a possibly-interesting approach to help reach students falls flat.

The researchers seemed to have used a buckshot, population-based approach. Previous research has suggested that we have some ideas about what kind of people are at most risk for depression — previous episodes of depression, anxiety or bipolar disorder (and a few other things); family history of depression (including parents); and socio-economic status. It’s a wonder the researchers didn’t try to better target their approach using some of these factors.

If you want to reach students, I suspect you also need to be where they are — less on email, and more on Facebook, Twitter, Skype and their iPhones. Or in their face.

Then you have to provide more personalized followup rather than just sending them some links or additional depression information. I suspect if they had received in-person visits or even just a telephone call, researchers would have seen a higher rate of students who sought out treatment.

I’m all for the use of technology to help improve access to mental health information and treatment (obviously!). But a study like this leaves me scratching my head saying, “That’s it?” Technology has so much potential, but only when it is harnessed and targeted appropriately.

Read the full article: E-mail Catches Some Cases of College Depression

 


Comments


View Comments / Leave a Comment

This post currently has 6 comments.
You can read the comments or leave your own thoughts.


    Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 26 May 2010
    Published on PsychCentral.com. All rights reserved.

APA Reference
Grohol, J. (2010). Email Not That Effective with College Depression. Psych Central. Retrieved on September 22, 2014, from http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2010/05/26/email-not-that-effective-with-college-depression/

 

Recent Comments
  • deflatedmom: I am a mother of a pregnant 18yr old. My daughter has a medical condition that requires her to be on...
  • John M. Grohol, Psy.D.: Don’t confuse a correlation with helping us understand the underlying cause of a...
  • SSlim: You are debunking that serotinin is touted as the sole cause of depression but every material that i have read...
  • Joey: Wow! I have to say that reading this article has made me feel much better and may help me to stop thinking that...
  • Rationalizer: Your story is as old as the hills. I do not judge you at all. I’ve been there myself. I can...
Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter


Find a Therapist
Enter ZIP or postal code