You really have to wonder at what the folks over at White Coat Notes, a health blog by The Boston Globe, were thinking when they wrote this about a recently published study:

Two thirds of prisoners nationwide with a mental illness were off treatment at the time of their arrest, according to a new study by Harvard researchers that suggests under-treatment of mental illness contributes to crime and incarceration. [emphasis added]

How can a survey of current prisoners suggest any type of causal relationship between crime and a medical or health condition? Would anyone suggest that because the same survey data found that prisoners are 31% more likely to have asthma, 55% more likely to have diabetes, and 90% more likely to have suffered a heart attack, that people who have asthma and who are “under-treated” contribute to “crime and incarceration”?? I guess no one bothers to actually read the studies any longer, or even have any type of skepticism when a doctor throws out comments that make no sense based upon their own data.

I guess I shouldn’t blame the author of the article, who was only reporting the ridiculous comments made by one of the Harvard researchers of the study:

“For many of them, treatment of their mental illness before their arrest might have prevented criminality and the staggering human and financial costs of incarceration,” said study author Dr. Steffie Woolhandler, an associate professor of medicine at Harvard and a primary care physician at the Cambridge Health Alliance’s Cambridge Hospital campus.

Really now? And what makes you say that? Because you wrongly believe there is some sort of correlation between having a mental illness (as opposed to asthma) and being more likely to commit a crime? But then again, I wouldn’t expect a primary care physician to be, well, a psychiatrist or mental health researcher who actually is an expert in such topics. So I have to wonder why such a physician feels perfectly comfortable commenting on possible causal relationships that their research had no way of showing.

There’s no doubt that if a person is taking their prescribed psychiatric medication, they’re possibly (probably?) going to be in a better place psychologically speaking. But how that’s related to the likelihood of committing a crime is beyond me, as there is no link between the two. Most people who take psychiatric medications do not commit crimes. And most criminals are not mentally ill.

Such discrimination still exists among researchers, despite the evidence that shows no such link exists (unless the person also has a substance abuse problem). We’ve written on this issue many times because the myth constantly gets repeated, even though it has little research support.

What the study did show is that prisoners are under-treated for their health and mental health conditions. That’s it. No surprise there, as prison systems tend to be under-funded and focused on simple warehousing these days, rather than helping a person reform or really improve themselves (at least in non-criminal ways).

Read the Boston.com article: Harvard study: Under-treatment of mental illness contributes to crime

 


Comments


View Comments / Leave a Comment

This post currently has 27 comments.
You can read the comments or leave your own thoughts.


    Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 18 Jan 2009
    Published on PsychCentral.com. All rights reserved.

APA Reference
Grohol, J. (2009). Undertreatment of Mental Illness Causes Crime?. Psych Central. Retrieved on October 21, 2014, from http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2009/01/18/undertreatment-of-mental-illness-causes-crime/

 

Recent Comments
  • Fight Depression: thank you for the wonderful description.
  • acaw: Although you might be correct to identify a certain infantilism in some men these days, you go astray in...
  • mom of 4: Well, my experience with my son’s ODD agrees with pretty much everything on here. I am going to write...
  • Diimund: Just about everything bad that could happen to a person in their life has happened to me – accept that...
  • monica: We are not talking about normal behavior issues here. Thèse are kids WHO get so angry they punch holes in...
Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter


Find a Therapist
Enter ZIP or postal code