World of Psychology

How Psychotherapy is Conducted Around the World

By John M Grohol PsyD
October 7, 2007

The August 2007 issue of the Journal of Clinical Psychology had an interesting series of articles looking at case studies of people who undergo psychotherapy around the world, including in Australia, Iran, Japan, South Africa, Argentina, Spain, Brunei, and Mexico.

The varied nature of these societies and their emphasis or stigmatization of mental health issues lends itself to a fascinating glimpse of how psychotherapy works (or doesn’t) in different settings.

For instance, psychodynamic approaches remain popular in many Spanish-speaking countries, but are slowly being replaced by more cognitive-behavioral therapies. The role of the family is also far more important, even in individual psychotherapy, than you typically see in the U.S., and so psychotherapy in countries like Iran have a heavy emphasis on how the family is a part of the problem and solution.

While the abstracts don’t do justice to the full articles, that is all that is available online (thanks dead-tree publishers!).


1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (2 votes, average: 3.5 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

2 Comments to
“How Psychotherapy is Conducted Around the World”

It is a group of interesting data, specially the ones in Burma and Iran; due to the social stress, I believe the work made by their specialists must not be easy.

Also, what is happening in South Africa is also similar to what should be happening in Italy, Spain and Portugal: the acceptance of a multicultural environment should be a priority for the societies and the learning to deal with it by the profesisonals of our field.

Finally, I am all about integration, since well made, and it’s interesting to notice that there were rare cases that mentioned it, and it was odd (perhaps of my own ignorance) that in Iran they say family is important, but instead of system therapy or positive psychotherapy (a paradigm created by the persian Dr.Peseschkian) they use CBT…

CBT is about all you get publically funded in Australasia (New Zealand and Australia). Part of it is due to the differences in our university system. The majority of clinical psychologists have a three year undergraduate degree, one year honours, one year masters, one year practicum, some additional coursework, and that is it.

Clinical Psychology programs are focused on training therapists to practice CBT. This is justified by their claiming that CBT is found to outperform alternative varieties of therapy for the conditions that patients are most likely to present with. As such it is the most cost effective variety of treatment to teach psychologists and (it is sometimes said) it would be unethical to train them or let them practice anything else!

Aside from that we do have councelling courses where people are trained in narrative therapy etc. ‘Councellor’ isn’t a trade-marked term in Australasia, however, though people with a Masters in Councelling (School of Education) are campaigning for it to be such. People with these qualifications typically don’t see people with mental disorders, however. They are more likely to work with relationship services (issues around domestic abuse) in drug and alchohol services, or in a rape crisis and / or lifeline type setting.

To get anything else (e.g., psychodynamic) you are typically looking at funding it yourself. While psychiatrists are taught a little about psychodynamic therapy it isn’t cost effective for the public system to employ psychiatrists to deliver therapy.

In New Zealand there is a focus on the family because of an emphasis in Maori values in healthcare across the board. That doesn’t translate into family systems therapy etc because of the focus on CBT by people who are trained to treat patients with mental disorders (Clinical Psychologists)

Join the Conversation! Post a Comment:


    Last reviewed: By John M. Grohol, Psy.D. on 7 Oct 2007

 


Recent Comments
  • Ayan: the article is really good
  • Janie: I’ve burned bridges in the past and it still lingers on from time to time..the whole reminder of what...
  • Katrin: I am not going to read your articles any longer, AND i may change my mind. I would perhaps do it just for a...
  • Katrin: BTW, I have lived for 35 years with the above and i know more than anyone on the subject. A plus B may be...
  • Katrin: What’s the point of throwing out these ‘loaded’ subjects and then abandoning a reader like...
Article Tools
Bookmark
Print
Email Friend


Stumble It!


Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter


Users Online: 740
Join Us Now!