Web 2.0 Question & Answer Sites - MetaFilter
I’ve long been a fan of MetaFilter for tapping into a part of the Internet meme, long before the words “social networking” and the gawd-awful meaningless “Web 2.0″ were coined. MetaFilter is “Web 2.0″ long before anyone knew that was cool.
So it’s not surprising that I found this thread to be interesting. When one of the pre-Web 2.0 sites is commenting on yet another more recent spate of Web 2.0 sites, well, you’re bound to get some negativity. But it also tells me something else — that Web 2.0, user-empowered communities are meaningless without some implicit meaning or structure. Flickr — photos. YouTube — videos. Delicious (I never know where to put the damned periods) — Links. Wikipedia — encyclopedia. Myspace — music. Yes, that’s right, it found its original popularity because of sharing music amongst unknown artists. It spilled into the teen peer group precisely for this reason. And then on to the rest of us.
Yahoo! Answers and Wondir — Well, apparently anything goes. And while Yahoo! can sustain such a service (think Yahoo! Groups, Mail, etc.), I question whether other general purpose services can endlessly tap into people’s well-meaning intentions, free time, and willingness to help others indefinitely. Wikipedia may also suffer from this concern, since you have to ask how long will people just continuously care about a project that isn’t their own. The answer is, nobody knows.
Sites focused on a single technology or topic will likely have an easier time with the future than those that try to be all things to all people. Once the atypical becomes common (and, in fact, overwheliming to online users), I think there may be a backlash to so many sites relying on “user generated” content to make money off of, without limits. Remember, the sites aren’t in it to give “users a voice” — they’re in it to make a profit.
I remain undecided about the future of such sites, but am probably still a little bearish on “Web 2.0″ sites without purpose or clear direction. Sure, for every Myspace, there’s a site like Facebook trying to cash in on the same idea to a different audience. But there are also the Friendster’s and Orkut’s of the world — sites virtually left in the dust after initial acclaim.
(2 votes, average: 3.5 out of 5)
Loading ...This entry was posted on Tuesday, August 15th, 2006 at 10:30 pm and is filed under General, Technology. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
2 Responses to “Web 2.0 Question & Answer Sites” (Pingbacks/trackbacks not shown below)
www.KnowBrainers.com is a great question and answer site that moderates the questions.
Yaniv Golan at 11:37 am on
September 1st, 2006
John,
I also found that thread fascinating. MetaFilter is a great resource and is one of the examples we’re looking at with respect when we try to imagine where we’d like to take Yedda.
Yedda strikes an interesting compromise between anything goes and a site focused on a single topic. Once you define (free form + assisted) the topics you are interested in, it automatically creates a filter that makes sure that you’re exposed only to Q&As related to these topics (unless you actively search for other topics of course).
There is a lot more in Yedda, like the fact that it keeps questions always-fresh using a unique active broker which gets attached to each question.
As for a clear purpose or direction, at least to us, it’s clear - to be the best place for exchanging personal knowledge. There is a still a way to go, but hey, you only need directions if you didn’t actually get there already, right? 
If you can find the time to try Yedda, I’d love to hear what you think of it.
Be a Part of the Conversation! Comment on this Entry Now:
www.KnowBrainers.com is a great question and answer site that moderates the questions.
John,
I also found that thread fascinating. MetaFilter is a great resource and is one of the examples we’re looking at with respect when we try to imagine where we’d like to take Yedda.
Yedda strikes an interesting compromise between anything goes and a site focused on a single topic. Once you define (free form + assisted) the topics you are interested in, it automatically creates a filter that makes sure that you’re exposed only to Q&As related to these topics (unless you actively search for other topics of course).
There is a lot more in Yedda, like the fact that it keeps questions always-fresh using a unique active broker which gets attached to each question.
As for a clear purpose or direction, at least to us, it’s clear - to be the best place for exchanging personal knowledge. There is a still a way to go, but hey, you only need directions if you didn’t actually get there already, right?
If you can find the time to try Yedda, I’d love to hear what you think of it.
